Journal of Social Political Sciences (JSPS)
Vol 7 No 3 (2026): August 2026

THE THE PROBLEMS OF JUST ENERGY TRANSITION IN WEST SUMATRA: ENERGY DEMOCRACY, ECOLOGICAL JUSTICE, COMMUNITY OWNERSHIP

Virtuous Setyaka (Andalas University Padang)
Sucy Delyarahmi (Andalas University Padang)
Apriwan (Andalas University Padang)



Article Info

Publish Date
20 Aug 2026

Abstract

The transition toward renewable energy is increasingly promoted as a pathway to decarbonization, energy security, and sustainable development. Yet renewable-energy expansion does not automatically constitute a just energy transition. This article examines the challenges of just energy transition in West Sumatra, Indonesia, through the lenses of energy justice, energy democracy, ecological justice, and community ownership. It employs a qualitative comparative case-study approach based on documentary research and recent field research at three renewable-energy sites: the floating solar photovoltaic project at Danau Singkarak, the Gunung Talang geothermal project, and the Muara Laboh geothermal project. The findings reveal a persistent governance gap between centralized energy-transition policies and local territorial realities. Participation remains largely administrative rather than deliberative; customary land rights are insufficiently incorporated into project governance; community-level economic benefits remain weakly institutionalized; and local communities are positioned primarily as beneficiaries or affected populations rather than co-owners and decision-makers. These conditions generate distrust and resistance, even where communities do not reject renewable energy itself. The article argues that such resistance can represent claims for procedural, recognition, distributional, and ecological justice. It further contends that energy democracy provides a crucial political dimension of just transition by addressing ownership and control. The article proposes a nagari-based energy-democracy framework combining deliberative participation, recognition of customary rights, ecological safeguards, binding benefit-sharing, and community or cooperative ownership. A genuinely just energy transition therefore requires redistributing not only energy benefits, but also political authority, economic value, ecological responsibility, and ownership

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jsps

Publisher

Subject

Humanities Decision Sciences, Operations Research & Management Education

Description

JSPS, Journal of Social-Political Sciences study the sociological impacts of political systems, change in political policies and administration. It also refers to the study of interdisciplinary aspects of politics and international relations, social anthropology, social policy, global public health, ...