Journal of Law and Legal Reform
Vol. 7 No. 4 (2026): October, 2026 (In Press)

Constitutionalizing Restorative Justice Based on Pancasila Values for Criminal Justice Reform in Indonesia

Markus Yohanis Hage (Faculty of Law, Universitas Nusa Cendana, Kupang)
Gerardus Bernadus Duka (Sekolah Tinggi Pastoral Keuskupan Agung Kupang, Kupang)
Yanto M.P. Ekon (Faculty of Law, Universitas Kristen Artha Wacana, Kupang)
Dhesy Arisandielis Kase (Faculty of Law, Universitas Nusa Cendana, Kupang)
Nizamuddin Alias (Faculty of Law, Universitas Kebangsaan Malaysia, Bangi)



Article Info

Publish Date
28 Oct 2026

Abstract

Restorative justice (RJ) has emerged as an important approach to criminal justice reform, emphasizing accountability, reparation of harm, victim participation, and the restoration of social relationships. In Indonesia, however, RJ is regulated through institutional instruments governing the police, prosecution service, and judiciary, raising questions about the consistency of its normative foundations, procedural safeguards, and accountability mechanisms. This article examines how restorative justice can be constitutionalized on the basis of Pancasila values and how these values can serve as the principal normative criteria for evaluating Indonesia’s restorative justice framework. Employing normative-doctrinal legal research, this study combines constitutional interpretation with a conceptual approach to examine the 1945 Constitution, relevant restorative justice regulations, and scholarly literature. The analysis develops a Pancasila Constitutional Compatibility Test based on eight analytical frames: respect for diversity within unity; compliance with shared rules and social agreements; mutual cooperation and the general welfare; morality and civility in law; humanity and justice; national integration and an inclusive public sphere; ethical deliberative democracy; and social justice. These frames translate Pancasila’s five fundamental principles into criteria for assessing the legitimacy and design of restorative justice. The findings indicate that existing institutional instruments provide pathways for restorative case resolution but do not establish a sufficiently coherent set of safeguards across the criminal justice process, particularly concerning voluntary and informed consent, protection against coercion, victim support, transparency, review mechanisms, and institutional accountability. This article’s principal contribution is a conceptual and normative assessment framework that connects Pancasila values with identifiable legal safeguards and institutional responsibilities. It argues that restorative justice reform requires harmonized minimum standards, transparent decision-making, effective oversight, and a stronger legal foundation to ensure that restorative outcomes protect human dignity, preserve legal certainty, and advance substantive justice.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jllr

Publisher

Subject

Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice

Description

The Journal seeks to disseminate information and views on matters relating to law reform, including developments in case and statute law, as well as proposals for law reform, be they from formal law reform bodies or from other institutions or ...