Jurnal Civil Engineering Study
Vol. 6 No. 02 (2026): Jurnal Civil Engineering Study

Seismic Response Comparison of Tidar Regional Hospital Using Equivalent Static, Response Spectrum, and Time-History Methods

Agustinus Sungsang Nana Patria (Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Semarang)
Pramesta Armanisag Pangestuti (Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Semarang)
Rahma Amalia Sinatria (Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Semarang)



Article Info

Publish Date
29 Oct 2026

Abstract

Earthquake analysis methods affect structural response and member demands. This study compares equivalent static, response spectrum, and time-history analyses of the Aster Inpatient Building at Tidar Regional Public Hospital in Magelang, a six-story reinforced-concrete structure on site class SD. The ETABS model uses a special moment-resisting frame system. Time-history analyses use the Sanriku Iwate 2011, Fukushima Chiba 2011, and Cook Strait 2013 records after spectral matching. The comparison parameters include base shear, modal characteristics, lateral displacement, stability coefficients, and moments and shear forces in selected members. The largest X-direction base shear occurred under the Sanriku record at 6,259.332 kN, while the largest Y-direction value occurred under response spectrum analysis at 5,771.447 kN. The Fukushima and Cook Strait responses were approximately 18–19% of the equivalent static values, indicating that scaling equivalence should be checked. Sanriku produced beam and column moments of 1,267.019 kN·m and 2,668.113 kN·m, respectively. The equivalent static and response spectrum methods produced larger reported lateral displacements than the three time-history records. The findings indicate that global and local responses should be considered together. Final assessment of interstory drift and stability requires consistent displacement definitions, spectrum parameters, units, and scale factors.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

CES

Publisher

Subject

Civil Engineering, Building, Construction & Architecture

Description

Jurnal Civil Engineering Study (JCES) contains writings about applications in the field of Civil Engineering. This application may come from all branches of civil engineering, be it structural, geotechnical, construction management, hydrology, transportation, and civil engineering informatics. So ...