The designation of a suspect is a crucial stage in criminal investigations and must comply with evidentiary standards stipulated in the Indonesian Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP) and reaffirmed by Constitutional Court Decision No. 21/PUU-XII/2014. In practice, however, inconsistencies often arise, as reflected in Pretrial Decision No. 1/Pid.Pra/2023/PN Cianjur concerning a traffic accident case. This article examines the constitutional standards for suspect designation under KUHAP and the Constitutional Court’s ruling, as well as their application in the relevant pretrial decision. The analysis reveals that a valid suspect designation requires at least two lawful pieces of evidence and prior examination of the prospective suspect as part of due process of law. In the Cianjur case, these requirements were formally met but substantively questionable regarding the quality and relevance of the evidence. This study underscores the need for consistent application of constitutional standards to ensure the effectiveness of pretrial proceedings as a judicial control mechanism.
Copyrights © 2026