Corruption is a criminal offence of an extraordinary nature, often referred to as an extraordinary crime. In its course, criminal acts of corruption have elements that must be fulfilled, one of which is proof of financial loss to the state. Proving the element of financial loss to the state often depends on an audit report from an independent institution that is constitutionally recognised and acknowledged as the only institution that can determine financial loss to the state, namely the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK). However, with the development of the law, the courts often use the audit results of the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (BPKP) instead. This matter of proof is regulated in Supreme Court Circular Letter Number 4 of 2016 (SEMA Number 4 of 2016), which raises the issue of dualism of audit authority between the BPK and BPKP in proving the element of state financial loss for the courts in Indonesia. This dualism then gave rise to a polemic regarding Decision No. 3448 K/Pid.Sus/2024 against Johnny G. Plate, in which the judge, in basing his consideration of the elements of the criminal act of corruption, used the audit results of the BPKP rather than the audit results of the BPK in his legal considerations and sentencing.
Copyrights © 2026