This study answers how a judge assesses evidence in a marriage annulment caused by the husband being found homosexual after the marriage, as granted in Jember Religious Court Decision Number 44/Pdt.G/2023/PA.Jr. Using normative legal research with a legal-principles approach, it examines the judge’s reasoning and its conformity with civil procedural law. The findings show that the judge built his conviction mainly on the Respondent’s admission and witness testimony, supported by electronic conversation evidence, and then granted the petition and annulled the marriage under Article 27 paragraph (2) of Law Number 1 of 1974 on Marriage. The reasoning is formally consistent with civil procedure, which only pursues formal truth, so medical evidence is not required. Even so, asserting “homosexuality” as a proven fact is the weakest part of the proof, because sexual orientation cannot be proven clinically and risks shifting the object of proof from the failure of the marriage’s purpose to the labelling of the Respondent. The study concludes that the annulment is more properly grounded on the proven mistaken belief that defeats the purpose of marriage, rather than on proving the homosexual condition itself.
Copyrights © 2026