The Decision Number 70/Pid.Sus-TPK/2024/PN.Jkt.Pst marks a new chapter in Indonesian anticorruption law enforcement by establishing ecological losses as a component of state losses subject to criminal sanction. This establishment triggers a fundamental dogmatic debate: can losses that are estimative and projective in nature—such as ecosystem damage and loss of biodiversity—be qualified as state losses under a criminal law regime that requires the certainty of actual loss? This article analyzes two issues: first, whether the determination of ecological losses in the said decision conforms to applicable legal provisions and principles of criminal justice; second, how criminal law responds to estimative ecological losses without sacrificing the certainty of criminal evidence. Using normative legal research methods and a conceptual-comparative approach, this article argues that the ecologization of state losses requires a conceptual reconstruction that bridges the precautionary principle in environmental law with criminal evidence standards. The analysis reveals that while the decision represents a breakthrough, it carries risks of legal uncertainty if not supported by a standardized methodology for calculating ecological losses.
Copyrights © 2026