Pena Justisia: Media Komunikasi dan Kajian Hukum
Vol. 25 No. 2 (2026): Vol. 25 No. 2 (2026): Pena Justisia

Analysis Of Defects Of Consent Due To Mistake (Dwaling) In The Annulment Of A Lease Agreement (A Case Study of Judgment No. 41/Pdt.G/2025/PN Gin)

Dhina Yustisia Arinta Putri (Unknown)
Dona Budi Kharisma (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
22 Oct 2026

Abstract

This article examines how the Gianyar District Court treated a mistake (dwaling) about the size of leased land as a defect of consent, and how annulment of the resulting deed affected the parties’ rights in Judgment No. 41/Pdt.G/2025/PN Gin. The Plaintiff had subleased 265 m² of a 1,950 m² parcel to Defendant I in 2016, yet the notarial Deed of Assignment of Lease Agreement No. 02 of 9 March 2018 recorded the full 1,950 m² as the leased object. Using normative legal research with statutory and case approaches and a deductive qualitative analysis of Articles 1320, 1321, and 1322 of the Indonesian Civil Code (KUHPerdata), the study finds that three objective indicators established the mistake: the transaction price, the physical condition of the land confirmed by an on-site inspection (descente), and the parties’ post-signing conduct. These show that the parties’ will covered only 265 m², so the error concerned the substance of the leased object (error in substantia). The Court declared the deed null and void; this article argues that nullity fits the additional 1,685 m², over which no will was ever formed, better than a classic voidable mistake. Annulment removed Defendant I’s claim to the whole parcel and left the 2016 sublease in force, while the Court rightly refused to order a new deed, since only the parties’ free consent can create one.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

hk

Publisher

Subject

Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice

Description

Pena Justisia aims to provide a forum for lecturers and researchers to publish the original articles about Law Science. Focus of Pena Justisia is publishing the manuscript of outcome study, and conceptual ideas which specific in the sector of Law science. We are interested in topics which relate ...