This article examines how the Gianyar District Court treated a mistake (dwaling) about the size of leased land as a defect of consent, and how annulment of the resulting deed affected the parties’ rights in Judgment No. 41/Pdt.G/2025/PN Gin. The Plaintiff had subleased 265 m² of a 1,950 m² parcel to Defendant I in 2016, yet the notarial Deed of Assignment of Lease Agreement No. 02 of 9 March 2018 recorded the full 1,950 m² as the leased object. Using normative legal research with statutory and case approaches and a deductive qualitative analysis of Articles 1320, 1321, and 1322 of the Indonesian Civil Code (KUHPerdata), the study finds that three objective indicators established the mistake: the transaction price, the physical condition of the land confirmed by an on-site inspection (descente), and the parties’ post-signing conduct. These show that the parties’ will covered only 265 m², so the error concerned the substance of the leased object (error in substantia). The Court declared the deed null and void; this article argues that nullity fits the additional 1,685 m², over which no will was ever formed, better than a classic voidable mistake. Annulment removed Defendant I’s claim to the whole parcel and left the 2016 sublease in force, while the Court rightly refused to order a new deed, since only the parties’ free consent can create one.
Copyrights © 2026