Controversial mathematics problems can elicit critical thinking, yet the task characteristics that make mathematical disagreement open to systematic examination remain insufficiently understood in geometry. This study identified empirical characteristics of controversial geometry problems associated with students' critical-thinking activities. An interpretive qualitative study informed by constructivist grounded theory involved 25 Year 11 students in a National Science Olympiad (OSN) program at a senior high school in Cirebon, Indonesia. This setting provided an information-rich case because students were familiar with non-routine mathematical problems, rather than representing the broader student population. Data comprised written responses to three geometry problems and semi-structured interviews with nine theoretically selected students. Analysis involved initial and focused coding, constant comparison, memo writing, theoretical sampling, and cross-case synthesis. Six task-level characteristics emerged: competing claims, contestable mathematical grounds, conceptual/relational/contextual tension, testable evidence, verification affordance, and decision-and-justification demand. Students' responses illustrated difficulties involving geometric referents, area calculations under spatial conditions, and comparisons between area and perimeter scaling. The interview revealed the use of definitions, axioms, alternative verification methods, and evidence-based reasoning. Three forms of tension were identified: object meaning, calculation versus spatial conditions, and linear versus multiplicative relationships. These findings provide an empirical account of how controversial geometry tasks elicit evidence-based critical thinking.
Copyrights © 2026