Metathesis: Journal of English Language, Literature, and Teaching
Vol. 10 No. 2 (2026): Metathesis: Journal of English Language, Literature, and Teaching

Comparative analysis of cognitive levels in “Critical Thinking” and “Think” tasks in Indonesian and Japanese EFL textbooks

Ahmad Ulliyadhi Satria Raharja (Universitas Islam Negeri Salatiga)
Mohammad Roisul Ashdaq (Universitas Islam Negeri Salatiga)
Andi Muhammad Syukri (Kumamoto University)



Article Info

Publish Date
31 Oct 2026

Abstract

In response to the national literacy challenge highlighted by Indonesia’s 2022 PISA results, which show that only 25% of Indonesian students have reached a basic level of reading proficiency, the Merdeka Curriculum emphasizes higher-order thinking skills (HOTS) within its learning materials. Although previous research indicates that tasks in earlier Indonesian English as a foreign language (EFL) textbooks were dominated by lower-order thinking skills (LOTS), recent changes in the design of reading tasks warrant further investigation. This study compares the cognitive domains of reading tasks explicitly labeled as “Critical Thinking” in the Indonesian EFL textbook series Bright Volumes 2 & 3 published by Erlangga, with those labeled as “Think” in the Japanese EFL textbook series New Horizon Volumes 2 & 3 published by Tokyo Shoseki. Employing a qualitative content analysis method based on the revised Bloom’s Taxonomy, which spans cognitive levels from “Remembering” (C1) to “Creating” (C6), this study analyzes a total of 90 tasks (63 from Bright and 27 from New Horizon). The findings reveal that within these specific task categories, higher-order thinking skills (HOTS) predominate in both textbook series, with no tasks at the “Remembering” (C1) level. However, there is a difference in the pattern of its distribution; the Indonesian Bright series heavily emphasizes the “Analyzing” (C4) and “Evaluating” (C5) levels, whereas the Japanese New Horizon series displays a more balanced distribution across the “Analyzing” (C4), “Evaluating” (C5), and “Creating” (C6) levels. These findings provide preliminary empirical evidence to inform the ongoing evaluation of English (EFL) textbooks and the design of supplementary materials in both countries.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

metathesis

Publisher

Subject

Education Languange, Linguistic, Communication & Media

Description

METATHESIS is a Journal of English Language, Literature, and Teaching published by Department of English Education, Faculty of Education and Teacher Training, Universitas Tidar. It is published twice a year in April and October. We accept manuscripts within the fields of: (1) English language ...