This study aims to analyse the accountability of public officials, particularly the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, in issuing and controlling nickel mining business permits in the Raja Ampat Islands, which have been contested over alleged environmental damage. The study uses normative legal research with statutory, case, and conceptual approaches. Legal materials, consisting of statutes, court decisions, official ministry press releases, and mainstream media reports, were collected through document study and analysed using a descriptive-analytical qualitative method based on legal, administrative, political, and information-disclosure accountability. The results show that accountability is layered because the permits were issued by different officials in different periods, while the minister bears official responsibility for supervision, evaluation, and revocation of permits. The revocation of four permits in June 2025 reflects corrective accountability. However, the different treatment of one company that remained in operation, the inconsistent interpretation among officials of the prohibition on mining on small islands, and the dispute over information disclosure indicate that accountability remains inconsistent, not yet preventive, and not fully transparent. The study recommends an independent audit, a single legal test for all permits, and publication of decision documents.
Copyrights © 2026