Studies of Indonesian digital da'wah have documented the mediatization of preaching, but none has empirically audited the link between preachers' scholarly competence and algorithmic audience reach across a stratified comparative sample. This study examines how five Indonesian preachers (Buya Yahya, Adi Hidayat, Khalid Basalamah, Hanan Attaki, Felix Siauw) construct religious authority on YouTube and how comment columns negotiate it. A qualitative comparative case analysis draws on 60 videos (1,800 coded transcript segments), 500 manually coded comments, and audio-validated per-citation speaker attribution. Findings reveal three authority modes: epistemic credential, hybrid epistemic gated, and positional host. Felix, the least credentialed, reaches the largest audience (decoupling ratio 12.7+) and cites the Qur'an more on secular podcasts, revealing a citation-extraction-by-host mechanism; symbolic affirmation dominates the credentialed preachers (61-76%), while Felix attracts substantive engagement (61%). Concretely, da'wah literacy education should distinguish substantive from performative engagement, and institutions should not equate engagement volume with transformation.
Copyrights © 2026