This paper examines the questionable phrase “Minor nature of the offence” in Indonesia’s Criminal Code. This phrase should be distinguished from the term “Minor offence” (bagatel), which refers to a specific type of petty crime. In contrast, “Minor nature of the offence” is a standard that lets judges grant a judicial pardon (rechterlijk pardon) despite someone being found guilty. While this flexible language gives judges more freedom, it can also lead to inconsistent decisions and unpredictable law enforcement. The paper uses normative legal research and both statutory and conceptual approaches to review legal sources and develop well-defined evaluation criteria. The results show that the current wording is vague, rendering decisions more subjective and thereby increasing the tension between justice and legal certainty (rechtszekerheid). To solve this, the study proposes a two-part framework that includes objective factors like minimal harm, no violence, and low financial loss, as well as subjective factors such as intent, personal background, and actions after offence. The paper suggests that the Supreme Court issue formal sentencing guidelines through a Supreme Court Regulation or Circular Letter to guarantee more consistent judicial decisions. Judges and law enforcement should also use teleological interpretation to balance flexibility with clear legal standards.
Copyrights © 2026