Misbah : Jurnal Pendidikan dan Pemikiran Islam
Vol. 2 No. 02 (2026): MISBAH: Jurnal Pendidikan dan Pemikiran Islam

DIVINE JUSTICE : THE THEOLOGICAL DEBATE BETWEEN THE MU'TAZILAH AND AHLUS SUNNAH

Raisa Zuhra Salsabila Awaluddin (UIN Sunan Kalijaga Yogyakarta)



Article Info

Publish Date
26 Oct 2026

Abstract

The discourse on God's justice is one of the central debates in classical Islamic theology that is closely related to the issues of human freedom (free will), destiny (qadar), and the relationship between reason and revelation, which this debate was not born in a vacuum but grew out of the chaos of the socio-political conditions of early Islam when the deterministic-fatalistic understanding of destiny was often exploited to legitimize the arbitrariness of rulers. Departing from the vortex of historical conflict, this literature review examines in depth how the concept of God's justice is understood diametrically by two major poles of thought, namely Mu'tazilah and Ahlus Sunnah, and explores whether divine justice philosophically requires real freedom of action for humans. The results of the literature synthesis show that the gap between the two stems from the fundamental epistemological question of moral authority; Mu'tazilah relies on objective rationality and believes that reason is able to recognize the standards of good and evil independently, so that God's justice logically absolutely requires the existence of real human freedom (khaliq li af'alihi) in order to maintain logic and rationality from the imposition of religious obligations (taklif). On the other hand, Ahlus Sunnah, especially the Ash'ariyah tradition, strongly rejects the use of human reason as a moral judge of God's actions, believes that justice is synonymous with the absoluteness of the Divine will itself, and formulates the theory of acquisition (kasb) as a middle way to maintain human moral accountability without having to reduce the slightest bit of God's omnipotence. In the end, the implications of this study confirm that the dialectic between the objective moral rationality of the Mu'tazilah and the affirmation of absolute sovereignty in the style of the Ahlus Sunnah is not just a history of obsolete theological debate, but a framework of thought that functionally remains very relevant as an ethical foundation in modern theological discourse, especially for dissecting the problems of human suffering, responding to social injustice, and understanding the limits of moral responsibility in the contemporary era.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

misbah

Publisher

Subject

Description

Misbah: Jurnal Pendidikan dan Pemikiran Islam, a journal published by the Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi Syariah (STIES) BABUSSALAM in print and online. STIES Babussalam is a higher education institution within the Pondok Pesantren Babussalam in Jombang. This journal is a scientific journal that will ...