Jurnal Jurisprudence
Vol. 16, No. 1, June 2026

The Legal Politics of Constitutional Courts in Judicial Review: Safeguarding the Constitutionality of Legislation in Indonesia, South Korea, Taiwan, and Brazil: -

Fajrian Noor Anugrah (Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Hukum Sultan Adam Banjarmasin)
Arief Budiono (Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta)
Restu Mufanti (University of Technology Sydney)
Muslimah Hayati (Magister Ilmu Hukum, Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Hukum Sultan Adam Banjarmasin)
agna azkia (Mahasiswa Magister Ilmu Hukum Sekolah Tinggi Sultan Adam Banjarmasin)
Vanka Lyandova (Saint Petersburg State University)



Article Info

Publish Date
18 Jun 2026

Abstract

Purpose of the study: This article examines the legal politics of Constitutional Court oversight in safeguarding constitutional supremacy through judicial review, using a comparative analysis of four jurisdictions across different regions: Indonesia, South Korea, Taiwan, and Brazil. It focuses on the institutional roles and legal mechanisms involved in ensuring the constitutionality of legislation. Methodology: This research employs a normative juridical approach and library research, drawing on legislation, judicial decisions, scholarly journals, and other relevant academic literature. Comparative legal analysis serves as the primary instrument for examining judicial review decisions and institutional practices across four jurisdictions. The collected data are interpreted descriptively and analyzed to identify similarities and differences in legal frameworks, judicial authority, and constitutional oversight. The study is prescriptive in nature, aiming to formulate recommendations for strengthening constitutional review mechanisms. Results: The findings indicate that judicial review systems across the selected jurisdictions employ different institutional arrangements and mechanisms to uphold constitutional supremacy. Judicial decisions serve as instruments for maintaining the balance of power among state institutions, preventing abuses of authority, and protecting citizens’ constitutional rights. The effectiveness of constitutional review also depends on the implementation of judicial decisions and the legal consequences arising from the invalidation of unconstitutional provisions. Applications of this study: This research offers comparative legal insights that may inform the development of constitutional oversight mechanisms. It emphasizes the importance of ensuring that legislation enacted by lawmakers complies with constitutional principles and that constitutional norms are not circumvented or violated. Novelty/Orginalty of this study: This study integrates the doctrine of the constitutionality of legislation, the declaratory-constitutive nature of Constitutional Court decisions, and the theory of authority to examine constitutional oversight. It highlights how judicial decisions not only declare legal provisions unconstitutional but also establish new legal conditions, while emphasizing checks and balances, judicial independence, and institutional accountability. Keywords: Comparative Legal Oversight, Constitutional Court, Judicial Review, Constitutionality of Legislation

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jurisprudence

Publisher

Subject

Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice

Description

Jurnal Jurisprudence is an academic journal published twice a year by the Magister Law Program of Universitas Muhammadiyah ...