Purpose of the study: This study aims to examine and reconstruct judicial reasoning in selected Indonesian court decisions on sexual violence against children, particularly Supreme Court Decision No. 574 K/Pid.Sus/2018 and Supreme Court Decision No. 813 K/Pid.Sus/2019, through a comparative analysis with the European Court of Human Rights decisions in M.C. v. Bulgaria and E.S. v. Slovakia. The study evaluates how judges interpret evidence and assess victim credibility while considering power imbalances and psychological vulnerability, with the objective of developing a victim-oriented judicial reasoning model that strengthens substantive justice and child protection. Methodology: This research employs a normative legal method using case and comparative approaches. The study analyzes the ratio decidendi of selected Indonesian and European court decisions concerning sexual violence against children. Through qualitative legal analysis, the study examines how judicial reasoning is constructed in relation to evidentiary assessment, victim testimony, psychological vulnerability, power imbalance, and the principle of the best interests of the child. Results: The findings indicate that judicial reasoning in Indonesia remains predominantly formalistic, emphasizing procedural legality and rigid evidentiary standards. Such an approach often neglects the psychological vulnerability of child victims, the existence of unequal power relations, and the principle of the best interests of the child. In contrast, European courts demonstrate a more progressive reasoning model by incorporating victim-oriented and trauma-informed perspectives that prioritize substantive justice and human rights protection. Applications: This study provides practical guidance for judges and policymakers in reformulating judicial reasoning to enhance the protection of child victims in criminal proceedings. Novelty/Originality: This research offers a novel contribution by integrating comparative judicial reasoning with a victim-oriented framework, proposing a reconstructed model that combines child-sensitive principles, contextual analysis, and human rights-based approaches. Keywords: child protection; comparative law; judicial reasoning; sexual violence; victim-oriented justice
Copyrights © 2026