Selecting geometry teaching methods requires attention to students’ opportunities to understand concepts and apply them in problem solving. This study aimed to describe and compare junior secondary students’ geometry learning outcomes following instruction through problem-solving and question-and-answer methods on cubes and cuboids. A quantitative approach compared two instructional groups using posttest scores. Participants comprised all 50 ninth-grade students at SMP Negeri Satap Lontoi, distributed across two existing classes of 25 students each. Data were collected using a ten-item constructed-response test and analyzed through descriptive statistics, an independent-samples t-test, and effect size calculations. The problem-solving group achieved a mean score of 78.20 with a standard deviation of 7.621, whereas the question-and-answer group achieved a mean of 73.60 with a standard deviation of 7.974. The mean difference of 4.60 points yielded t(48) = 2.085 and p = .042, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.164–9.036 points. Hedges’ g was 0.581, indicating the magnitude of the between-group score difference. The problem-solving group achieved higher posttest scores in this context. However, using one class per method, lacking baseline ability analysis, and not accounting for classroom clustering limit causal conclusions. These findings may inform geometry instruction that provides opportunities to develop solution strategies and discuss their underlying reasoning.
Copyrights © 2026