This study examines the effectiveness of the Agam Makmur Program, a productive-zakat economic empowerment scheme administered by BAZNAS Kabupaten Agam, West Sumatra, using the Context-Input-Process-Product (CIPP) evaluation framework of Stufflebeam. Distribution records show a striking anomaly: budget realization reached nearly full absorption in 2024 but fell to roughly half of the allocated plan in 2025, while the number of assisted mustahik declined even as the approved budget ceiling increased. Employing a qualitative case-study design, data were gathered through in-depth interviews with BAZNAS leaders, amil (program staff), and mustahik beneficiaries, supplemented by documentary analysis of institutional records. Findings indicate that context and input components were reasonably well established, but process-level weaknesses in business mentoring (pendampingan) and product-level shortfalls in venture sustainability constrained the program's transformative impact. The study argues that budget absorption alone is an inadequate proxy for effectiveness, and that mentoring intensity is the pivotal mediating factor between capital disbursement and mustahik economic independence. These findings contribute to the theoretical understanding of productive-zakat management and offer practical implications for BAZNAS institutions seeking to strengthen post-disbursement accompaniment.
Copyrights © 2026