Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search

Just Energy Transition dalam Hubungan Internasional Kontemporer: Debat, Kontestasi, dan Politik Keadilan Global Asep Agil Supriatna; Wildan Ilmanuarif Shafar
Indonesian Social Science Review Vol. 4 No. 1 (2026)
Publisher : Yayasan Lentera Avanya Nagari

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.61105/issr.v4i1.399

Abstract

This article maps the Just Energy Transition (JET) debate in contemporary International Relations (IR) literature and identifies its fundamental conceptual contestations. Using qualitative document analysis combined with reflexive thematic analysis of peer-reviewed publications from 1995 to 2025, this study purposively selected literature representing diverse IR theoretical approaches and Global North-South perspectives. The analysis identifies four main themes: International Political Economy and Global Governance, Political Ecology and Energy Justice, Energy Democracy and Socio-Technical Transitions, and Public Policy and Development Studies. Their interaction produces four conceptual contestations: reform versus structural transformation, universalism versus normative particularism, speed versus inclusivity, and epistemic asymmetry between the Global North and Global South. The findings demonstrate that JET is not merely a technical policy matter but a field of global political contestation reflecting deep ontological and epistemological differences about justice, power, and world order transformation. This study contributes the first systematic conceptual mapping of JET debates from an IR lens. Artikel ini memetakan perdebatan Just Energy Transition (JET) dalam literatur Hubungan Internasional (HI) kontemporer dan mengidentifikasi kontestasi konseptual fundamentalnya. Menggunakan analisis dokumen kualitatif dengan reflexive thematic analysis terhadap publikasi peer-reviewed periode 1995-2025, penelitian ini memilih literatur secara purposif yang merepresentasikan beragam pendekatan teoretis HI serta perspektif Global North dan Global South. Analisis mengidentifikasi empat tema utama: Ekonomi Politik Internasional dan Tata Kelola Global, Ekologi Politik dan Keadilan Energi, Demokrasi Energi dan Transisi Sosio-Teknis, serta Kebijakan Publik dan Studi Pembangunan. Interaksi antarkeempat tema menghasilkan empat kontestasi fundamental: reformasi versus transformasi struktural, universalisme versus partikularisme normatif, kecepatan versus inklusivitas, serta asimetri epistemik Global North-South. Temuan menunjukkan bahwa JET dalam perspektif HI bukan sekadar persoalan teknis-kebijakan, melainkan arena kontestasi politik global yang mencerminkan perbedaan ontologis dan epistemologis mengenai keadilan, kekuasaan, dan transformasi tatanan dunia.
Religious Legitimacy and Extractive Politics: The Disarticulation of Human Security in Indonesia’s Mining Concessions Fajar Imam Zarkasyi; Dwiki Yulian Reynaldi; Wildan Ilmanuarif Shafar
TEMALI : Jurnal Pembangunan Sosial Vol. 9 No. 1 (2026): TEMALI : Jurnal Pembangunan Sosial
Publisher : Universitas Islam Negeri Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15575/jt.v9i1.52060

Abstract

This study examines how religious legitimacy shapes and reorders human security discourse within policies granting mining concessions to religious organizations in Indonesia. It departs from the growing involvement of religious actors in extractive sectors and the resulting implications for the protection of people, the environment, and affected communities. Using a qualitative approach grounded in critical discourse analysis and the hegemony theory of Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe, the study analyzes state statements, elite pronouncements from religious organizations, and national media discourse through systematic coding and relational mapping with NVivo. The findings show that religious concepts—most notably maslahat—operate as a hegemonic nodal point that binds claims of development, welfare, moral obligation, and nationalism into a single chain of equivalence that stabilizes mining concession policies. Within this configuration, human security is not explicitly rejected; rather, it becomes disarticulated and reduced to technical and procedural concerns through the normalization of ecological risks, livelihood vulnerabilities, and social impacts as routine consequences of development. Furthermore, the involvement of religious organizations marks a transformation of religious roles from moral guardians to extractive actors through a mechanism of antagonism displacement, whereby structural conflicts between the state and citizens shift into internal moral debates within organizations. Theoretically, this study affirms that human security constitutes a contested discursive arena rather than a neutral normative framework. It contributes to extractive politics scholarship by demonstrating how religious authority can function as a hegemonic mechanism that stabilizes extractive development while marginalizing ecological and social protection.