Didik Iskandar
Makassar State University

Published : 2 Documents Claim Missing Document
Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search

Representation Of Indigenous Papuans In The Bureaucracy Of Southwest Papua Province: A Representative Bureaucracy Analysis Dewiyanti Rengen; Hasniati Hasniati; Muh. Akmal Ibrahim; Didik Iskandar
Journal of Communication and Social Sciences Vol. 4 No. 2 (2026): Journal of Communication and Social Sciences
Publisher : CV. Doki Course and Training

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.61994/jcss.v4i2.2213

Abstract

Affirmative action has increased the presence of Indigenous Papuans (OAP) in the bureaucracy of Southwest Papua Province, yet numerical representation does not automatically guarantee substantive representation in positions that determine policy direction. This study analyzes the quality of OAP representation through three components of representative bureaucracy: passive representation, linking conditions, and active representation. Using an interpretive qualitative approach with an embedded case study design in the Provincial Government of Southwest Papua, the study involved 25 informants, with data from in-depth interviews, documentation study, and limited observation, analyzed through theory-driven thematic analysis, pattern matching, and explanation building. The findings show that OAP representation is high in number and evenly distributed across ranks, but uneven by role weight—concentrated in supporting positions, while policy-determining positions remain limited. The five linking conditions (discretion, domain relevance, competence and legitimacy, leadership support, accountability) remain weak. Active representation is limited in the policy arena but stronger in service delivery, accompanied by the symptom of substantive roles being carried by other actors. The three components form a tiered chain that breaks at the middle, so that representation is strong in presence but shrinks in influence. The weak conversion stems from fragile evidence-based legitimacy and the absence of capacity development, so that strengthening representation requires building institutional conditions rather than merely adding numbers.
Adaptive Structuration within Isomorphism in Strengthening BKPSDM of Southwest Papua Province Ignatius Randhy Frieder; Badu Ahmad; Muh. Akmal Ibrahim; Didik Iskandar
Journal of Communication and Social Sciences Vol. 4 No. 2 (2026): Journal of Communication and Social Sciences
Publisher : CV. Doki Course and Training

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.61994/jcss.v4i2.2214

Abstract

Adopting national structures, systems, and procedures does not automatically yield institutional effectiveness; what matters is the process of appropriation and adaptation by organizational actors, which becomes critical under the constraints of an affirmation setting. This study analyzes adaptive structuration across three dimensions—structure as rules and resources, the duality of structure and agency, and appropriation and adaptation—in the adoption of personnel systems and procedures at BKPSDM of Southwest Papua Province. An interpretive qualitative case-study design was used, relying on in-depth interviews, observation, and documentation, analyzed with the interactive model of Miles, Huberman, and Saldaña under Adaptive Structuration Theory. Rules, resources, systems, and procedures are complete on paper but not yet meaningful in practice; officials’ capacity to interpret, negotiate, and modify national provisions is low, so they tend to receive structure passively; and appropriation stops at the procedural level and is often misaligned with the systems’ original intent. The study yields a typology of adaptation—procedural, pragmatic, and substantive. The three dimensions form a chain that breaks in the middle because the agency dimension is weak, so the adaptation that forms is dominated by the symbolic type; weak agency is the decisive link, while the typology becomes a basis for practice-based institutional-maturity measurement