The 1945 Constitution of Indonesia promises recognition and respect for customary law communities and their traditional rights, yet the distance between that promise and the lived reality of indigenous communities remains considerable. This article examines the legal challenges that impede the recognition of indigenous customary law in Indonesia and assesses the prospects for strengthening its constitutional protection. Using a normative juridical method that combines statute, case, and conceptual approaches, the study analyzes the constitutional text, sectoral legislation, Constitutional Court jurisprudence, and scholarship published between 2021 and 2026. The findings are presented in two parts. First, the article shows that recognition is structurally fragmented: Articles 18B(2) and 28I(3) of the Constitution are conditional, delegate the operative rules to statutes and regional regulations, and are implemented through sectoral regimes in forestry, agrarian, village, environmental, and criminal law that impose divergent and burdensome requirements. Second, the article evaluates the corrective potential of Constitutional Court decisions, the accelerated recognition of customary forests, the living-law provision of the new Criminal Code and its implementing regulation, and the long-pending Indigenous Peoples Bill. It argues that durable protection requires a comprehensive statute grounded in self-identification and participation, harmonized sectoral regimes, criminal law safeguards, and a shift from a permission-based to a rights-based model of recognition