Differences in approaches to understanding religious texts pose a challenge for Islamic education in developing students’ critical, proportional, and inclusive religious understanding within pluralistic societies. Textualism emphasizes the authority of religious texts, while contextualism considers historical, social, and cultural contexts and the normative objectives of religious messages. This study aims to analyze the dialectic between textualism and contextualism in Islamic education and examine their contribution to developing inclusive religious understanding. A qualitative library research approach was employed by examining relevant literature on textualism, contextualism, Islamic education, inclusivism, and contemporary religious understanding. Data were analyzed thematically through identification, categorization, comparison, and conceptual synthesis. The findings show that textualism maintains the authority and consistency of Islamic normative values, whereas contextualism facilitates the interpretation of religious messages in changing social realities. The study contributes a pedagogical framework that integrates textual reading, contextual analysis, critical reasoning, interpretive dialogue, and social reflection. Rather than treating the two approaches as mutually exclusive, their integration can strengthen religious literacy and enable students to maintain normative foundations while appreciating diverse interpretations. Thus, Islamic education can foster inclusive religious understanding through critical, proportional, and responsible engagement with texts and contexts.