The Indonesian National Police (Polri) must strike a balance between upholding public order and citizens' constitutional right to free speech when dealing with anarchic protests. The potential of criminalizing discretion-based measures and the use of force is increased when there is no clear legal framework for police protection in emergency situations. This study looks at how police officers are protected legally in certain situations and suggests a more adaptable legal framework that is in line with the practical requirements of law enforcement. This study examines laws, judicial decisions, international norms, and empirical analyzes of pertinent situations using a normative juridical method. The results show that police officers' legal protection is still inadequate and disjointed, and that the existing legal system is unable to protect officers working in high-risk situations. Legal reconstruction is therefore required, with a focus on three main areas: (1) specific legal regulations addressing police protection, such as updates to Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs), discretionary protection clauses, and a clear implementation guide for the proportionality principle; (2) internal legal support mechanisms to guaranty equitable legal assistance for officers in critical incidents; and (3) improved accountability mechanisms that uphold police professionalism while guaranteeing legal protection. In order to promote better professionalism within Polri and increase public confidence in law enforcement organizations, this study emphasizes the necessity of adaptive policing legislation that strike a compromise between responsibility and legal protection.