Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search

Impaired Neutrality: A Propensity That Occurs Among Indonesian Bureaucrats in the Election Sangyub Ryu; Naufal Virindra
Policy & Governance Review Vol 7 No 1 (2023): January
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v7i1.622

Abstract

This paper explores the propensity of neutrality disruption among Indonesian civil servants during political elections. It aims to provide empirical evidence to prove that some Indonesian civil servants have the proclivity to violate neutrality by supporting political candidates in a campaign or through social media during the elections. This research was conducted with qualitative methods by literature review, examining policy documents, and a descriptive study to provide an overview of the theoretical normative and practical findings. This research utilized the Indonesian Civil Service Commission (KASN RI) report which showcased 1,399 neutrality violation reports and 982 neutrality violation cases among Indonesian civil servants in 2020 (2020 was the year of 270 simultaneous heads of regional elections in Indonesia), making Indonesia among the “few & self-interest” sphere countries in the modified dimension of interest and societal spheres framework. As the way out from the neutrality infringement paradox, this paper proposed a collaborative approach between government agencies to overcome civil servant neutrality violations and strategies to reduce abuse of power by the head of the government agency during the elections. The implication of this study is to remind the bureaucracy that dynamics and disharmony in implementing neutral competence and political responsiveness inside the bureaucracy occur during elections. Academically, this study is significant in showcasing the complex relationship between neutral competence and political responsiveness in bureaucracy. Practically, the study is substantial for the bureaucracy to learn how to prevent and be immune from political influence during the election.
PARADOKS SISTEM MERIT: ANALISIS POTENSI MASALAH PADA PENGISIAN JABATAN PIMPINAN TINGGI SEBAGAI PENGGERAK KINERJA PEMERINTAHAN Naufal Virindra
Civil Service: Jurnal Kebijakan dan Manajemen PNS Vol 20 No 1 (2026): Jurnal Kebijakan dan Manajemen PNS
Publisher : Badan Kepegawaian Negara | The National Civil Service Agency

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.61133/pns.v20i1.503

Abstract

This research employs a literature review to establish a theoretical framework for the merit system, government performance, and a case study of paradoxes, with a focus on potential problems in filling executive service positions (JPT) as a driver of government performance. Furthermore, theories related to the merit system and government performance are juxtaposed with case studies or potential problems that may arise in filling JPT positions, reflecting gaps in the ideal framework. Four potential paradoxes were identified in the selection process for JPT positions. First, there are potential problems with the authority of the elected officials (PPK) to select the best JPT candidates; second, potential conflicts of interest within the open selection committee; third, potential loopholes in the paper writing method in the open selection process; and fourth, problems in filling JPT positions through the talent management (MT) mechanism. To prevent these paradoxes and hinder government performance, this study proposes three strategies. First, encouraging the PPK to implement the principle of "political goodwill," second, adjusting provisions and creating technical guidelines to address legal gaps during the open selection process, and third, evaluating the policy of filling JPT positions through MT, recognizing the potential for "sunset law".