Critical thinking is a key competence in science learning; however, teacher-centered instruction can restrict students’ opportunities to investigate phenomena, analyze evidence, and formulate conclusions independently. This study examined differences in the improvement of critical thinking skills between fifth-grade students taught through guided inquiry and those receiving conventional instruction, and described students’ responses to guided inquiry. A quantitative quasi-experimental approach with a nonequivalent control group design was employed. The participants were 60 students from two intact classes in one elementary school, selected through purposive sampling (30 students per class). Data were collected using a 20-item critical thinking test based on Ennis’s five indicators (basic clarification, bases for a decision, inference, advanced clarification, and rhetorical strategies) and a 12-item student response questionnaire based on the ARCS model. Because the classes differed significantly at baseline and the posttest data were not normally distributed, improvement was analyzed using normalized gain (N-gain), the Wilcoxon signed-rank test, and the Mann-Whitney U test. Both classes improved significantly, but the experimental class showed a larger improvement than the control class (mean N-gain 0.647 vs. 0.331, both in the moderate category; U = 129.000, p < .001), with the clearest differences in advanced clarification and rhetorical strategies. Students’ responses to guided inquiry were positive (78.34%). The findings suggest that guided inquiry is associated with greater improvement in fifth-grade students’ critical thinking in science learning on human body systems and growth, although non-random assignment, baseline differences, and a single-school setting limit causal interpretation.