Background: Father involvement in childrearing encompasses a range of roles and daily interactions, but differences in how fathers engage in everyday caregiving may not be captured by an overall involvement score.Objectives: To compare patterns of father involvement between families with high and low Inventory of Father Involvement (IFI) scores, based on mothers’ experiences.Method: A qualitative comparative study using in-depth interviews with 10 mothers of children aged 5-9 years in Jonggol, Indonesia. Using extreme-case sampling, five mothers from the highest and five from the lowest IFI scores (completed by 130 mothers) were selected. Interviews followed a common guide and were analyzed thematically.Result: In the high-IFI group, fathers were involved across several areas of daily life, including communication, discipline, emotional support for mothers, and in some families education. In the low-IFI group, caregiving was more often centered on mothers, although patterns varied. One low-IFI case showed intensive digital communication despite long work-related absence, whereas a high-IFI case included physical punishment of a child. Low-IFI accounts also included angry rejection of children and, in one family, violence toward the mother. Involvement was not adequately represented by presence or communication frequency alone, and higher involvement did not mean equal sharing of domestic work. Findings reflect mothers’ perceptions.Conclusion: Differences lay mainly in how far fathers were integrated into everyday caregiving and in the quality of father-child interactions. Efforts to strengthen father involvement should address interaction quality, emotional responsiveness, and shared responsibilities, and should prioritize family safety where violence is reported.