Baḥth al-Masāʾil is a pesantren deliberative forum where students address contemporary legal issues through classical texts and collective reasoning. However, authoritative citations do not necessarily ensure factual accuracy or appropriate legal conclusions. This article documents a methodological feedback session conducted by the first answer formulator before senior authentication at the Baḥth al-Masāʾil al-Kubrā, held on 1 October 2025 at Perguruan Islam Pondok Tremas, Pacitan, East Java. This community engagement activity integrated problem-centred learning and formative feedback. Seven written group answers addressing disputed rice-field ownership and zakat on professional income and gold savings were examined through documentary and thematic analysis, supported by classical and contemporary legal sources. Four recurring issues emerged: unverified ownership assumptions, mismatches between textual evidence and legal categories, confusion between zakat frameworks, and numerical errors. These findings informed two outputs: an eight-stage reasoning guide and a three-layer audit matrix addressing factual validity, evidence relevance, and decision authority. The proposed framework provides a practical quality-control checkpoint while preserving senior scholars' final authority. Although improved student competence was not measured, this approach offers a low-burden methodological contribution to Islamic education management in pesantren
Copyrights © 2025