Journal of Novel Engineering Science and Technology
Vol. 4 No. 03 (2025): Journal of Novel Engineering Science and Technology

Comparison of Multi-Face Detection Performance on Images Using Haarcascade, Dlib, and RetinaFace

Saputra, Sabarudin (Unknown)
Jufriansah, Adi (Unknown)
Mu’min, Muhammad Amirul (Unknown)
Akbar, Muhammad (Unknown)
Jayanto, Deni Luvi (Unknown)
Hernita, Ayu (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
27 Dec 2025

Abstract

Multi-face detection presents a significant challenge in computer vision, especially in environments with limited hardware resources. This study compares the performance of three multi-face detection methods—Haarcascade, Dlib (HOG and CNN), and RetinaFace—using a subset of the WIDER FACE dataset in a CPU-only environment without GPU acceleration. The experiment was conducted in two stages using a total of 300 images from the WIDER FACE dataset, which reflect real-world variations such as pose, scale, illumination, expression, and occlusion. Performance evaluation was carried out using precision, recall, F1-score, accuracy, and processing time as metrics. The results show that RetinaFace consistently outperforms the other methods, achieving superior metrics in Recall (0.92), F1-score (0.93), and Accuracy (0.88) on Subset A, and leading across all metrics on Subset B. While Dlib-CNN demonstrates high detection performance, it suffers from very slow processing time. In contrast, Haarcascade delivers the fastest processing speed but performs poorly in terms of evaluation metrics. The experiments also reveal that RetinaFace is the most consistent and reliable method based on standard deviation values of precision (0.01), recall (0.11), F1-score (0.07), and accuracy (0.11). Overall, this study contributes valuable insights for selecting efficient face detection methods under constrained resource conditions.

Copyrights © 2025






Journal Info

Abbrev

JNEST

Publisher

Subject

Computer Science & IT Control & Systems Engineering Decision Sciences, Operations Research & Management Environmental Science Mechanical Engineering

Description

Journal of Novel Engineering Science and Technology is a multi-disciplinary international open-access journal dedicated to natural science, technology, and engineering, as well as its derived applications in various fields. JNEST publishes high-quality original research articles and reviews in all ...