Jurnal Hukum
Vol 2 No 1 (2026): Jurnal Hukum

The classification of change orders in EPC Turnkey projects by Indonesian state-owned enterprises: Navigating between business risk and state financial loss

Bagus Satrio Utomo Prawiraharjo (Universitas Muhammadiyah Cileungsi)



Article Info

Publish Date
13 Aug 2026

Abstract

State-owned enterprises in Indonesia extensively utilize Engineering, Procurement, and Construction turnkey contracts for strategic infrastructure development, inherently requiring contractual flexibility through change order mechanisms to accommodate project complexity and uncertainty. However, stringent oversight of state finances creates significant legal ambiguity regarding whether cost increases resulting from legitimate project variations automatically constitute state financial loss under Indonesian anti-corruption legislation. This study employs normative legal research with doctrinal analysis to examine the juridical construction of state financial loss within the context of contract variations, analyzing constitutional court jurisprudence, audit board methodologies, and corporate governance principles. The research develops a tripartite classification framework distinguishing change orders as ordinary business risks requiring documentation, valid technical justifications necessitating cost-benefit analysis, or potential state financial losses involving unlawful acts. Findings indicate that the Constitutional Court's interpretation requiring actual and definite losses as material elements of corruption offenses creates substantial evidentiary burdens for auditors and law enforcement, while the Business Judgment Rule offers limited protection for directors due to inconsistent application. The study concludes that regulatory harmonization between project management paradigms and criminal law frameworks is essential to provide legal certainty for decision-makers while safeguarding public funds against fraudulent contract modifications.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

Jh

Publisher

Subject

Description

Jurnal hukum sought to be a reputable source of information on legal and judicial research as well as a peer-reviewed platform. Juril covers material that is analytical, objective, empirical, and contributes to the growth and dynamics of legal studies, particularly in Indonesia-Universitas ...