The differences between the organizing principles of Kenneth Waltz's anarchic system and Immanuel Wallerstein's hierarchical system require synthesis,given that both theories represent magna opera in international studies and are mutually complementary in explaining contemporary international political dynamics. Employing a metatheorizing approach,this study argues that Wallerstein's conceptualization of the periphery and semi-periphery as geographic areas must be reformulated as sovereign states to maintain relevance in explaining state-led economic development. Concurrently,because the hierarchy of skills and capital generates disparities in the distribution of economic capabilities,skill and capital catch-up,alongside innovation,serve as essential strategies for improving a state's position within the international system. Wallerstein's concept of the hierarchy of production structures, traditionally understood as a deep structure,must be repositioned as a surface structure. This is due to its material nature and its function in mediating the effects of the deep structure on system outcomes,analogous to Waltz's concept of the distribution of capabilities. Although Wallerstein also reflects the concept of anarchy by positing the absence of a centralized political mechanism in the world economy,unlike Waltz, he utilizes capitalism as the primary driving variable of the world system,resulting in a dual deep structure. By reformulating this deep structure of capitalism into a mercantilist organization of capitalism with an epiphenomenal nature,it can be integrated into international political theory. This integration serves as an explanatory factor for why the unipolarity of the United States has not culminated in a world empire, contrary to the apprehensions of Waltz and his realist contemporaries.
Copyrights © 2026