EMPIRISMA: JURNAL PEMIKIRAN DAN KEBUDAYAAN ISLAM
Vol. 35 No. 2 (2026): Empirisma: Jurnal Pemikiran dan Kebudayaan Islam

Negotiating Religious Tolerance And Criticism In The Digital Sphere: A Discourse Analysis of The “Different But Together” Podcast, Episode 120

Derry Ahmad Rizal (UIN Sunan Kalijaga)



Article Info

Publish Date
18 Sep 2026

Abstract

The digital era in Indonesia is marked by a crisis of interfaith harmony, reflected in the proliferation of hate speech in cyberspace. The phenomenon of “religious haters” has emerged as a systematic threat that exploits social media algorithms to spread anti-religious propaganda and fuel societal polarization, thereby creating ethical ambiguity regarding the boundary between freedom of expression and acts of intolerance. This study aims to analyze the discourse construction regarding religious tolerance and the phenomenon of “religious haters” in Episode 120 of the “Berbeda tapi Bersama” podcast on the Noice app, as well as to identify how the boundaries of tolerance are defined in the new digital space. Using a descriptive-analytical qualitative case study method, this research examines the subject matter through Norman Fairclough’s three-dimensional model of Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA), which encompasses the dimensions of text, discursive practices, and socio-cultural practices. Primary data were obtained from the audio transcript of Episode 120, which features a dialogue between Habib Jafar and Bhante Dhira Puñño, supplemented by secondary data consisting of audience interactions and relevant scholarly literature. The results of the analysis at the text level indicate that the podcast constructs a discourse of inclusive tolerance through the use of casual, dialogic, and humorous language to reduce theological-dogmatic tensions. The term “religious haters” is constructed as a sociological label for both internal and external groups that cross the ethical boundaries of respect for religious beliefs. In terms of discursive practices, there is a shift in religious authority from a formal-institutional model to an egalitarian, personal-digital one, in which religious messages are interactively produced and consumed by an active audience through comment sections. Meanwhile, at the level of social practice, this podcast serves as a counter-narrative to the culture of hate and the attention economy on social media, which often exploit issues related to ethnicity, religion, race, and intergroup relations (SARA). This study concludes that digital podcasts seek to construct a narrative of religious moderation as a counter-narrative to polarization and hate speech

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

empirisma

Publisher

Subject

Religion Arts Humanities Social Sciences

Description

Focus The focus of this journal is to publish the results of research and thoughts on Islamic studies in the form of research articles and book reviews and thoughts. Scope since 2017 the journal focuses more on various dimensions of Islamic thoughts and cultures with the scope limited to the ...