Punggawa Global Research
Vol. 1 No. 5 (2026): Punggawa Global Research: October

The State Does Not Count the Same Dead: The Politics of Homicide Measurement Across Criminal Justice and Public Health Systems

Zul Khaidir Kadir (Universitas Muslim Indonesia)



Article Info

Publish Date
01 Oct 2026

Abstract

Homicide statistics were often treated as unusually comparable because lethal events depended less on victim reporting than many non-lethal offences. This methodological study examined whether that assumption survived differences between criminal justice and public-health recording systems. Official WHO and UNODC documentation was audited for source provenance, counting units, classification rules, and time-series breaks. A symmetric System Recording Differential was then stress-tested through negative-binomial Monte Carlo simulations, followed by a persistence experiment and a tipping-point analysis for deaths of undetermined intent. The audit showed that WHO mortality observations had a clear civil-registration origin, whereas UNODC national homicide data could originate in either criminal justice or public-health systems, making database labels insufficient proxies for provenance. Under a fixed 25 percent recording ratio, the simulated differential remained centred near its true log ratio across baseline homicide rates from 0.25 to 40 per 100,000, while absolute rate differences expanded mechanically. Observed annual ratios also sharply attenuated latent temporal persistence. The findings supported provenance verification, symmetric modelling, and explicit classification sensitivity before cross-system homicide gaps were given institutional explanations.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

pgr

Publisher

Subject

Description

Social Sciences and Humanities, such as sociology, political science, law, criminology, anthropology, history, philosophy, cultural studies, communication studies, linguistics, and psychology; Education and Pedagogical Studies, including curriculum development, educational technology, learning ...