This article aims to analyze the dichotomy between traditional and modern Islamic education, identify the strengths and limitations of both paradigms, and formulate a direction for the development of an integrative, worldview-based Islamic education. This study employs a qualitative method using a content analysis approach to examine the works of Islamic educational thinkers as well as relevant journal articles, books, and theses published between 2020 and 2025. The data were analyzed through a process of coding, thematic categorization, content interpretation, and cross-source synthesis. The research findings indicate that the dichotomy between traditional and modern is a historical construct that does not fully reflect the integrative nature of the Islamic intellectual tradition. Traditional education has strengths in the continuity of scholarship and the cultivation of adab, but faces challenges in responding to change, whereas modern education is more open to scientific developments but faces challenges in maintaining Islamic epistemological and spiritual foundations. These findings highlight the importance of integrating a worldview that connects knowledge and values through the coherence of objectives, curriculum, methods, assessment, and teacher competencies. Consequently, the development of Islamic education must be directed toward substantive integration so that modernization does not erode Islam’s epistemological identity and tradition does not stagnate.
Copyrights © 2026