Indonesian Journal of Elementary and Childhood Education
Vol. 7 No. 3 (2026): Edisi September 2026

Game-Based Learning and Critical Thinking in Elementary Education: A Critical Evidence Synthesis for Think Trace Design

Aldi Anugrah (University of Mataram)
Samsul Rasidin (University of Mataram)
Muhamad Sofyan Afandi (University of Mataram)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Sep 2026

Abstract

Game-based learning (GBL) has been linked to critical thinking, yet skills, dispositions, and motivation are distinct outcomes. This review examines empirical evidence on educational games and measured critical-thinking skills among elementary-school pupils and derives design implications for the proposed Think Trace game. ERIC and GARUDA exports for 2021–2026 yielded 1,014 source records. After removal of four duplicates, 1,010 records underwent title–abstract screening assisted by lexical rules. Thirty database reports were sought; three were unavailable, 27 were assessed in full, 11 were excluded with documented reasons, and 16 met the review’s operational criteria. One additional eligible study was located through citation searching, giving 17 studies in the qualitative synthesis. Evidence came from seven comparative studies, seven single-group studies, and three classroom-action studies. Across the corpus, gains and associations were frequently reported, but nonrandomised groups, outcome measurement differences, and uncontrolled pre–post designs limit causal interpretation. Think Trace is proposed as a design model integrating evidence selection, justification, decisions, diagnostic feedback, and revision, not as an intervention of proven effectiveness. Screening was performed by one analyst with rule-based assistance, and search filters varied across periods; these methodological limits are made explicit. No pooled effect size or certainty rating is claimed.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

ijece

Publisher

Subject

Education Languange, Linguistic, Communication & Media Social Sciences Other

Description

Indonesian Journal of Elementary and Childhood Education (IJECE) merupakan jurnal ilmiah peer-reviewed yang didedikasikan sebagai platform diseminasi hasil pemikiran dan penelitian bagi mahasiswa, guru, dosen, praktisi, serta peneliti. Jurnal ini berfokus pada pengembangan ilmu pengetahuan di bidang ...