International Journal of Marine Engineering and Applications
Vol 3 No 2 (2026): September 2026

COMPARATIVE EFFECTIVENESS OF MANUAL ULTRASONIC TESTING (UT) AND RADIOGRAPHIC TESTING (RT) FOR WELDING DISCONTINUITIES DETECTION IN CRA CLAD PIPE

Supriyatna, Endang (Unknown)
Nugroho, Nur Yanu (Unknown)
Hardianto, Didik (Unknown)
Suwasono, Bagiyo (Unknown)
Aditya, Bagus Kusuma (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Sep 2026

Abstract

The integrity of Dissimilar Metal Welded (DMW) joints in Corrosion Resistant Alloy (CRA) clad pipes is critical for offshore infrastructure. However, the highly anisotropic, coarse-grained dendritic structure of austenitic Inconel 625 overlays causes severe acoustic attenuation and scattering, rendering conventional shear wave testing ineffective. This study evaluates a Manual Ultrasonic Testing (MUT) methodology utilizing 4 MHz focused longitudinal waves and dual-element (TRL) probes to penetrate these metallurgical boundaries. A 28-inch API 5L X65/Inconel 625 clad pipe mockup (60.57 mm total thickness) featuring 9 fabricated discontinuities (EDM notches and volumetric targets) was inspected and cross-validated against Radiographic Testing (RT). MUT achieved a 100% detection rate, correctly sizing internal flaws such as Flaw 7 (cluster porosity: 2–7 mm depth, 21 mm length, 3 mm height), which RT (88.9% detection rate) failed to identify due to geometric thickness limitations and 2D projection constraints. The optimized MUT configuration consistently achieved a Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) ≥ 3:1 (≥ 6 dB), with structural noise floor levels maintained between 13% and 30% of Full Screen Height (FSH). By providing precise 3D spatial localization and vertical height profiling capabilities absent in RT. This study validates that the proposed MUT methodology satisfies the strict compliance criteria of DNVGL-ST-F101 and ASME Section V.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jurnal

Publisher

Subject

Control & Systems Engineering Energy Engineering Mechanical Engineering Transportation

Description

International Journal of Marine Engineering and Applications is a peer-reviewed, open-access journal dedicated to advancing the field of marine engineering and its diverse applications. With a focus on promoting high-quality research and innovative solutions, IJMEA is a premier platform for ...