examining two court decisions, namely Decision Number 1/Pid.Sus-Anak/2024/PN Lhokseumawe and decision [2023] SGHCF No. 1 of 2023/1. The problem formulation is how the two jurisdictions regulate the elements of theft, the age limit of criminal responsibility, and the punishment imposed on children as perpetrators. This study uses a normative juridical method with a comparative approach to legislation, court decisions, and related legal doctrines. The results of the Indonesian study emphasize the protection of children through diversion, guidance, and restrictions, as seen in the Lhokseumawe District Court decision which imposed guidance sanctions. In contrast, Singapore emphasizes prevention by providing rehabilitative measures, as reflected in the SGHCF decision that directed the child to be placed on probation and enrolled in a boarding school program. The conclusion is that differences in legal philosophy influence the pattern of handling, but both countries still prioritize protection and prevention of repeat offenses.
Copyrights © 2026