Ihsanika : Jurnal Pendidikan Agama Islam
Vol. 4 No. 2 (2026): Juni : IHSANIKA : Jurnal Pendidikan Agama Islam

Dari Sistem Simbol Menuju Tradisi Diskursif dan Pembentukan Subjek Etis: Konsekuensi Epistemologis Pergeseran Geertz–Asad–Mahmood bagi Studi Islam

Anif Latifah Nur Ainiah (UIN Raden Mas Said)
Hamdan Maghribi (UIN Raden Mas Said)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Jun 2026

Abstract

This article analyzes the epistemological consequences of the conceptual shift from Clifford Geertz’s interpretive anthropology to Talal Asad’s concept of discursive tradition and Saba Mahmood’s account of ethical subject-formation for the construction of objects and research design in Islamic Studies. Unlike readings that treat the three thinkers as successive stages of theoretical development, this article argues that their relationship constitutes a series of epistemological reconfigurations: Geertz locates meaning within symbolic systems; Asad mounts a genealogical critique of the universal category of “religion” and positions Islam as a discursive tradition; while Mahmood questions the liberal assumption of agency and demonstrates the formation of ethical capacity through embodied practice. Using comparative conceptual analysis of the thinkers’ primary works, with secondary literature serving as interlocutors, the article also criticizes all three perspectives: Geertz’s culturalism, Asad’s normative tendencies, and the centrality of piety in Mahmood’s work. The analysis shows that these shifts transform what counts as the object of Islamic Studies, the kinds of questions considered valid, the conception of Muslim actors, and the epistemic position of the researcher. These consequences are demonstrated through an analytical vignette on Indonesian majelis taklim.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

IHSANIKA

Publisher

Subject

Religion Education

Description

Pendidikan Islam Berbasis Al Quran dan HaditsMedia, Metode, strategi, Pemanfaatan Teknologi dan Sumber Belajar dalam Pendidikan Islam, Kajian Tokoh Pendidikan Islam, Kurikulum Pendidikan Islam, Sejarah Pendidikan Islam, Filsafat Pendidikan Islam, Penelitian tentang Pendidikan Islam, Isu tentang ...