Reading comprehension is a crucial aspect of English language learning, as it fosters vocabulary development, grammatical understanding, and overall fluency. Nevertheless, Indonesian students perform below the OECD average on the PISA reading literacy assessment. This research analyzes text types and reading comprehension question levels in Work in Progress, a government textbook widely used in tenth-grade senior high school, compared with PISA reading materials, using Barrett's Taxonomy framework. To ensure data reliability, a qualitative descriptive approach was employed, involving document analysis, semi-structured interviews, and questionnaires administered to Senior High School English teachers. The findings reveal that the book consists primarily of basic texts and targets LOTS at the literal level. Conversely, PISA materials incorporate diverse text types and emphasize inferential and evaluative skills based on the Barrett Taxonomy level that correspond to HOTS. Teachers view textbooks as instructional tools for developing basic reading skills which are integrated in cognitive, whereas PISA serves as a benchmark for advanced critical literacy assessments. The research emphasizes the importance of selecting textbooks aligned with worldwide standards, particularly in promoting HOTS. These findings are valuable for educators, policymakers, and curriculum developers seeking to improve reading instruction and prepare students for international assessments
Copyrights © 2026