Critical thinking is an essential 21st-century competency, yet Indonesian students’ attainment remains low and classroom instruction is still largely transmissive. Problem-Based Learning (PBL) is widely recommended as a remedy, but existing studies tend to be partial, rarely explain the underlying mechanisms, and seldom address the conditions for implementation in Indonesia. This study aims to analyze how PBL implementation contributes to students’ critical thinking, through which mechanisms, and under which moderating conditions. Using a qualitative systematic literature review guided by PRISMA, 20 articles published in 2020–2024 were retrieved from Google Scholar, ERIC, Scopus, and Garuda, and analyzed through thematic analysis and narrative synthesis. The findings show that PBL tends to improve critical thinking consistently at primary, secondary, and tertiary levels through five mechanisms: cognitive conflict, metacognition, knowledge contextualization, argumentative reasoning, and self-regulation. Its effectiveness depends on problem design quality, teacher facilitation competence, implementation duration, and classroom climate, and is constrained by curriculum load, teacher competence gaps, student resistance, and limited infrastructure. The study concludes that PBL is effective when implemented with quality and supported by policy, and recommends its systematic integration into the curriculum alongside continuous teacher training.
Copyrights © 2026