Al-hikmah : International Journal of Islamic Studies
Vol. 1 No. 1 (2025): JUNI

Rethinking Financial Responsibility in Muslim Families: A Critical Analysis of Nafaqah in Classical and Contemporary Islamic Jurisprudence

Muhammad Alfi Syahrin (Institut Ahmad Dahlan Probolinggo)
Raudhotul Jannah (Universitas Muhammadiyah Berau)
Sitti Farahtiyah (Masjid Bandar Seri Putra Malaysia)



Article Info

Publish Date
20 Feb 2025

Abstract

The classical doctrine of nafaqah in Islamic family law generally establishes the husband as the primary financial provider, a framework historically developed alongside gendered assumptions concerning marital roles, authority, and economic dependency. However, contemporary Muslim families increasingly exhibit dual-earner arrangements, female  breadwinners, unequal economic capacities, and more reciprocal patterns of household decision-making, generating a significant normative tension between inherited jurisprudential doctrines and changing socio-economic realities. This study aims to critically reassess the concept of nafaqah by examining its underlying legal assumptions, comparing classical and contemporary Islamic jurisprudential formulations, and developing a more context-responsive framework of financial responsibility within Muslim families. Employing a qualitative doctrinal research design, the study utilizes a comparative and critical approach to classical fiqh literature, contemporary Islamic legal scholarship, Qur’anic principles, and the conceptual frameworks of maqāṣid al-sharīʿah, reciprocity, justice, and family welfare. The analysis demonstrates that although classical jurisprudence provides a coherent framework for protecting family subsistence, its predominantly husband-centered allocation of financial responsibility becomes insufficient when treated as an immutable legal structure. Contemporary reinterpretations indicate that the ethical objectives of nafaqah can be preserved while its implementation is recalibrated according to mutual cooperation, proportional economic capacity, and the welfare of the family. The study proposes a shift from exclusively gender-based responsibility toward a reciprocal and capacity-sensitive model, contributing to the development of more equitable and contextually responsive Islamic family law.

Copyrights © 2025






Journal Info

Abbrev

alhikmah

Publisher

Subject

Religion Humanities Education Environmental Science Other

Description

Al-Hikmah: International Journal of Islamic Studies is a peer-reviewed, open-access academic journal that focuses on the study and development of Islamic thought and civilization across disciplines. Published biannually, the journal serves as a platform for scholars, researchers, and practitioners ...