Intellect : Indonesian Journal of Learning and Technological Innovation
Vol. 5 No. 2 (2026): Intellect : Indonesian Journal of Learning and Technological Innovation

Development and Preliminary Evaluation of an AHP-Based Decision Support System for Teaching Method Recommendations in a Madrasah

Rendi Kurniyawan (Universitas Islam Negeri Sjech M. Djamil Djambek Bukittinggi)
Liza Efriyanti (Universitas Islam Negeri Sjech M. Djamil Djambek Bukittinggi)



Article Info

Publish Date
07 Nov 2026

Abstract

This study developed and preliminarily evaluated SIPPERS, a web-based decision support system designed to provide teaching-method recommendations at MTs Laboratorium UIN Bukittinggi. The reported development process combined needs assessment through observation and an interview, Agile-oriented software development, and the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). The decision hierarchy comprises three criteria (learning-style category, classroom participation, and learning comprehension), nine subcriteria, and five instructional alternatives. The reported criterion weights were 0.633, 0.260, and 0.106, with a criterion-level consistency ratio of 0.048. Ten documented black-box scenarios passed. Functional-suitability and compatibility assessments reported scores of 52/52 and 12/12, respectively, while seven educational staff members provided a usability score of 1,004/1,050 (95.62%). A documentation audit identified an alternative-priority vector that does not sum to one, leaving the reproducibility and pedagogical validity of the recommendations unresolved pending the original comparison matrices. The evidence supports preliminary software implementation and technical evaluation; it does not establish that the recommendations improve learning outcomes or are optimal for individual learners. Abstrak Penelitian ini mengembangkan dan mengevaluasi secara awal Sistem Personalisasi Pembelajaran Siswa (SIPPERS), yaitu sistem pendukung keputusan berbasis web untuk menyajikan rekomendasi metode mengajar di MTs Laboratorium UIN Bukittinggi. Pengembangan menggabungkan analisis kebutuhan melalui observasi dan wawancara, tahapan pengembangan perangkat lunak yang dilaporkan sebagai Agile, dan Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). Hierarki keputusan memuat tiga kriteria—gaya belajar, karakteristik keaktifan, dan daya tangkap—sembilan subkriteria, serta lima alternatif metode pembelajaran. Bobot kriteria yang dilaporkan adalah 0,633; 0,260; dan 0,106, dengan Consistency Ratio (CR) tingkat kriteria sebesar 0,048. Sepuluh skenario black-box berstatus berhasil; rekap penilaian functional suitability dan compatibility masing-masing mencapai 52/52 dan 12/12, sedangkan tujuh pengguna memberikan skor usability 1004/1050 (95,62%). Audit naskah menemukan ketidaksesuaian normalisasi pada satu vektor alternatif AHP sehingga validitas keputusan dan reproduksibilitas pembobotan masih memerlukan data sumber. Penelitian ini menunjukkan implementasi dan evaluasi teknis awal perangkat, bukan bukti ketepatan pedagogis rekomendasi ataupun peningkatan hasil belajar.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

intellect

Publisher

Subject

Computer Science & IT Education Electrical & Electronics Engineering

Description

The Intellect : Indonesian Journal of Learning and Technological Innovation aims to promote research and scholarship on the innovation of technology in secondary and higher education, as well as promote effective practice, and inform policy in education. The Intellect publishes papers related to ...