This paper examines the need to reform hate speech criminalization in Indonesia and proposes a harm-based legal framework to ensure legal certainty and safeguard the constitutional right to freedom of expression. Using normative legal research, this study analyzes relevant statutory provisions, legal doctrines, and constitutional principles governing hate speech and freedom of expression in Indonesia. The analysis reveals that the current regulatory framework remains fragmented and lacks a clear and operational definition of hate speech, creating broad interpretive discretion and a risk of overcriminalization. These weaknesses may blur the distinction between harmful hate speech and legitimate criticism, political expression, and dissent, thereby contributing to a chilling effect on freedom of expression. In response, this article proposes a harm-based framework that assesses criminal liability through contextual harm, mens rea, the likelihood and severity of harm, and the principles of legality, necessity, and proportionality. The proposed framework seeks to establish clearer boundaries for criminal intervention while preventing the excessive restriction of constitutionally protected expression. The article argues that reforming hate speech criminalization requires not only clearer statutory definitions but also a more constrained and context-sensitive approach to enforcement consistent with democratic values and constitutional guarantees of freedom of expression.
Copyrights © 2026