Enigma in Education
Vol. 4 No. 2 (2026): Enigma in Education

Instructional Alignment of Learning Objectives, Practice Tasks, and Assessments in an Open-Access Solid-State Chemistry Course: A Two-Dimensional Revised Bloom's Taxonomy Analysis

Sarah Armalia (Department of Natural Sciences, Barelang Study Center, Tanjung Pinang, Indonesia)
Kevin Setiawan (Department of Chemical Engineering, CMHC Research Center, Palembang, Indonesia)
Neva Dian Permana (Department of Social Sciences, CMHC Research Center, Palembang, Indonesia)



Article Info

Publish Date
01 Nov 2026

Abstract

Background. Judging instructional alignment among learning objectives, practice tasks, and assessments requires attention to substantive task demands, and surface action-verb frequencies alone are not enough. Objective. To evaluate instructional alignment across the written curriculum of MIT OpenCourseWare 3.091SC (Introduction to Solid-State Chemistry) with the two-dimensional Revised Bloom's Taxonomy. Methods. A rubric-based documentary curriculum analysis covered 35 sessions, nine modules, 176 explicit learning objectives, and 62 task documents (213 pages). The documents held 260 parent problems and 494 labeled task units, from which five within-type duplicates, 25 figure-restricted units, and seven context-insufficient units were excluded, leaving 457 unique codable task units, including 345 primary tasks (253 homework, 33 quiz, and 59 module examination units), alongside 175 codable objectives. Taxonomic distributions were evaluated with 24-cell overlap, 5,000 module-cluster bootstrap resamples, leave-one-module-out jackknife bounds, and six sensitivity specifications. Results. Learning objectives emphasized C2 Understand (95/175, 54.3%) and Conceptual knowledge (101/175, 57.7%), whereas primary tasks emphasized C3 Apply (237/345, 68.7%) and Procedural knowledge (250/345, 72.5%). Aggregating C1–C3 covered 330/345 primary tasks (95.7%), yet C1–C2 made up only 93/345 (27.0%). Mean module-level 24-cell overlap was 0.620 (95% bootstrap CI: 0.490–0.743) for objectives with practice and 0.595 (0.498–0.690) for objectives with assessments. The mean C3 difference between assessments and practice was +0.6 percentage points (95% CI: −10.6 to +13.0). Conclusion. Written tasks operationalize conceptual objectives mainly through quantitative and representational C3 application. No systematic C3 escalation from homework to examinations was found. Dual-rater calibration is a planned next step.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

edu

Publisher

Subject

Humanities Education Languange, Linguistic, Communication & Media Mathematics Other

Description

Focus Enigma in Education focused on the development of education fields for human well-being. Scope Enigma in Education publishes articles which encompass all aspects of education fields, especially all type of original articles, review articles, narrative review, meta-analysis, systematic review, ...