Cosmogov: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan
Vol 12, No 2 (2026)

NEGOTIATING STRUCTURE AND AGENCY: A PRELIMINARY STUDY OF RELIGIOUS CIVIL SOCIETY AND MINING CONCESSIONS IN INDONESIA

Mustofa, Mustabsyirotul Ummah (Unknown)
Mikail, Ahmad (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
01 Nov 2026

Abstract

This paper explores how structuration occurs in the granting of mining permits to religious organisations in Indonesia. Not only does the granting permits change the role of religious organisations from environmental advocates to mining actors, it also change state-civil society relations. As a preliminary study, it seeks to establish an analytical basis for understanding how participation in a state-regulated extractive sector may affect organizational autonomy and the relationship between religious CSOs and the state. Rather than assuming that mining involvement necessarily results in co-optation or weakens environmental advocacy, the study treats these outcomes as questions requiring further empirical investigationUsing Giddens' structuration theory, these changes can be understood in terms of the duality of structure. The first aspect how actors change due to the application of structures and how structures change due to the nature of actor agency. This preliminary research employs a qualitative approach with discourse analysis to examine the initial level of structurationin the structure of significance. Secondary data derived from official statements of religious organisations regarding the acceptane of mining permits, as well as other relevant documents, were explored during the period of 2024-2025. The results of the research point to the duality of structures that occurs in the granting of mining permits to religious organisations in Indonesia. Granting mining permits transforms the role of religious organisations, making them active participants in the extractive mining industry and causing a shift in relations between civil society and the state. Conversely, religious organisations use mining permits to generate profits for their civic activities, providing broader benefits. However, this dual structure will continue to be tested in terms of space and time, given that the real dynamics and impacts of mining activities carried out by religious organisations are not yet apparent.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

cosmogov

Publisher

Subject

Social Sciences

Description

COSMOGOV: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan is peer-reviewed Journal published by the Department of Government Science, Faculty of Social and Political Science, University of Padjadjaran. Published twice a year in April and October. COSMOGOV publishes various concept of thinking or ideas and the research in ...