Kasta: Jurnal Ilmu Sosial, Agama, Budaya dan Terapan
Vol. 6 No. 4 (2026): October

The Closed Loop of Selection and Remedy in Indonesian Immigration Administrative Sanctions

Ferroka Putra Wathan (Universitas Kader Bangsa Palembang)
Nafasa Istiqoza (Universitas Kader Bangsa Palembang)
Rizki Ramadhani (Universitas Kader Bangsa Palembang)
Abuyazid Bustomi (Universitas Kader Bangsa Palembang)



Article Info

Publish Date
31 Oct 2026

Abstract

Indonesian immigration law lists six forms of Tindakan Administratif Keimigrasian, or immigration administrative action, as though interchangeable, when some are alternatives, one a consequence, and others conditional on circumstances the rest exclude. Neither that ordering nor any criterion of choice is stated, and proportionality is absent from the eight codified principles of good governance. A ministerial regulation governing the field entered force in March 2025 and has drawn little study. Scholarship explains concentration on removal by sovereignty, capacity, or reviewability, but has not compared what a remedy restores across the sanction forms of one regime, nor joined selection to remedy as one chain. This study asks how the norms construct that choice, by what routes proportionality may bind it, and how far a successful objection restores the earlier position. It is normative legal research combining statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches, supported by performance reporting for one immigration office from 2022 to 2025, two field statements, and Dutch legislation as enacted. Four conditions interlock. Read as enacted, no instrument below the statute was directed to supply criteria. Proportionality binds only after a court ruling a statutory finality clause discourages. Every measure recorded by form at the observed office is removal, though a comparator office shows milder forms usable. A successful objection restores fully for one form alone and, for removal, defers relief to a later arrival while execution proceeds. Criteria for selection and force of remedy are one problem. Three additions are proposed, each attached to the instrument that would carry it.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

kasta

Publisher

Subject

Education

Description

KASTA adalah Jurnal Ilmu Sosial, Agama, Budaya dan Terapan dibawah lembaga Bale Literasi . Jurnal ini terbit tiga kali setahun, yaitu bulan April,Agustus dan Desember, ini memuat tentang ilmu-ilmu sosial, keagamaan, baik dalam pemikiran Islam,dan kajian Islam lainnya, kajian tetang budaya serta ilmu ...