The accusation that Islam is anti-Black has become one of the most controversial issues in contemporary Islamic discourse, particularly following the emergence of the Black Lives Matter movement and the growing academic attention to the history of slavery in Islamic civilization. This article critically analyzes how cultural relativism operates in the interpretation of ḥadīths related to slavery and race, with a primary focus on Jonathan A.C. Brown’s Islam and Blackness (2022). The study employs library research with a critical-hermeneutic approach, applying Emilio Betti’s four canons of objective hermeneutics to evaluate the methodological consistency of Brown’s reading of the ḥadīth corpus, classical matn criticism, and historiographical data on slavery in Muslim societies. The findings yield two interrelated levels of analysis. First, cultural relativism operates through five social-epistemic dimensions in Islamic ḥadīth criticism: ḥadīth canonization, social prejudice, matn criticism methodology, the thought of individual scholars, and Sufi symbolism. Second, evaluation through Betti’s four canons shows that Brown’s approach is generally consistent in terms of the autonomy of the object, coherence of meaning, and historical correspondence, yet remains less explicit in disciplining his own pre-understanding as a Muslim academic in North America. These dimensions reveal that the Islamic ḥadīth scholarly tradition possesses internal critical mechanisms, rooted in the principle of naqd al-matn since Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah (d. 751 AH), which have repeatedly been employed to reject racial narratives, although their application has varied according to historical contexts. This article contributes to contemporary ḥadīth studies by offering an analytical framework of five dimensions of cultural relativism for rereading ethically problematic religious texts, thereby avoiding both moral anachronism and uncritical apologetics.
Copyrights © 2026