This qualitative case study identified indicators of students’ speaking anxiety across the pre-activity, while-activity, and post-activity stages of speech activities in the English Club at MA Mu’allimin Sawah Dangka. Thirteen active English Club members of Class XI-B served as primary informants, with the English Club tutor as a supporting informant. Data were collected through a non-participant observation checklist of sixteen indicators and semi-structured interviews, both built on three dimensions of speaking anxiety; communication apprehension, test anxiety, and fear of negative evaluation across five meetings, and were analyzed using Miles et al.’s (2014) interactive model. The findings show that communication apprehension was the most consistent dimension, with all five indicators observed in every meeting and confirmed by twelve of the thirteen students reporting nervousness before performing. Test anxiety was mainly expressed through fear of forgetting: students repeatedly checked their speech, depended on notes, and twelve of thirteen reported going blank at least once, though visible tension tied to a test-like situation appeared in only two of five meetings. Fear of negative evaluation was present but less consistent; although discomfort and embarrassment were observed, twelve of thirteen students reported no strong fear of peer judgment, viewing mistakes as normal in learning together. The tutor linked students’ continued dependence on notes partly to habits formed through Qur’anic memorization. The study concludes that speaking anxiety in this Islamic school extracurricular setting was dominated by communication apprehension and concern over forgetting prepared content, while fear of negative evaluation remained comparatively minor.
Copyrights © 2026