cover
Contact Name
Mochammad Tanzil Multazam
Contact Email
tanzilmultazam@umsida.ac.id
Phone
-
Journal Mail Official
p3i@umsida.ac.id
Editorial Address
Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo Majapahit 666 B, Sidoarjo, East Java Indonesia
Location
Kab. sidoarjo,
Jawa timur
INDONESIA
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review
ISSN : -     EISSN : 25989928     DOI : https://doi.org/10.21070/ijler
Core Subject : Economy, Social,
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review (IJLER) is published by Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo four times a year. This journal provides immediate open access to its content on the principle that making research freely available to the public supports a greater global exchange of knowledge.This journal aims is to provide a place for academics and practitioners to publish original research and review articles. The articles basically contains any topics concerning Law and Economics. IJLER is available in online version. Language used in this journal is Indonesia or English.
Arjuna Subject : Ilmu Sosial - Hukum
Articles 865 Documents
Legal Implications of Broadcasting Rights for Indonesian Esports Competitions: Implikasi Hukum Hak Siar Kompetisi Esport Indonesia Alfito Angger Dwiyono; Mochammad Tanzil Multazam
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1666

Abstract

General Background: The development of esports in Indonesia has increased the economic value of broadcasting rights and created new legal issues within the digital media environment. Specific Background: Esports competitions differ from conventional broadcasting because their distribution relies heavily on digital platforms, streaming services, and video game intellectual property. Knowledge Gap: Existing legal frameworks provide several bases for protecting broadcasting rights, but their application to esports remains unclear, particularly concerning the status of rights holders, digital platforms, enforcement mechanisms, and the legal relationship between game developers and tournament organizers. Aims: This study examines the regulation of esports broadcasting rights in Indonesia, identifies weaknesses in the available legal protection, and analyzes the legal implications and need for regulatory development. Results: Using normative legal research with statute and conceptual approaches, the study finds that esports broadcasting rights are addressed through the Copyright Law, Broadcasting Law, Electronic Information and Transactions Law, and Civil Code. However, these regulations remain fragmented and do not specifically accommodate the digital characteristics of esports. Legal protection is available through preventive and repressive mechanisms, but illegal restreaming, cross-jurisdictional violations, overlapping legal regimes, unclear platform responsibilities, and limited legal literacy remain challenges. Novelty: This study focuses on the specific legal characteristics of esports broadcasting and the interaction between intellectual property, broadcasting, contracts, and digital platforms. Implications: Harmonization and clarification of existing legal norms, technical regulatory guidance, licensing standards, and stronger cooperation among relevant stakeholders are needed to provide greater legal certainty. Key Findings Highlights Existing Indonesian legal instruments address several aspects of competition broadcasting, but their application remains fragmented. Unlicensed restreaming, cross-border violations, and unclear platform responsibilities complicate legal enforcement. Regulatory clarification, licensing standards, and stakeholder cooperation are identified as necessary measures for greater legal certainty. Keywords : Broadcasting Rights, Esports Competitions, Digital Platforms, Legal Protection, Regulatory Harmonization
The Dynamics of Determining National Disaster Status in the Context of Disaster Management in Indonesia: Dinamika Penetapan Status Bencana Nasional dalam Rangka Penanganan Bencana di Indonesia Intan Azizah Tuz Zuhriyah; Rifqi Ridlo Phahlevy
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1667

Abstract

General Background: The designation of national disaster status in Indonesia remains subject to differing applications because clear and measurable criteria have not been established. Specific Background: Law Number 24 of 2007 provides indicators including the number of casualties, property losses, infrastructure damage, affected area, and social and economic consequences. Knowledge Gap: The existing framework does not specify measurable thresholds for these indicators, while previous studies have not specifically examined the uncertainty arising from differences in designation across major disaster events. Aims: This study analyzes the criteria for determining national disaster status under Law Number 24 of 2007 by comparing several major disaster events in Indonesia. Results: Using normative legal research with statutory and legal politics approaches, the study finds that designation is not determined solely by statutory indicators but also involves considerations such as local government capacity, governmental conditions, coordination, and policy considerations. Comparative analysis of Aceh, Yogyakarta, Sidoarjo, Palu, and Sumatra demonstrates differences in the application of statutory indicators. Novelty: The study examines the lack of measurable criteria through comparative analysis of major disaster events and highlights the need for further regulation under Article 7 paragraph (3). Implications: Clearer and measurable criteria through a Presidential Regulation are needed to provide greater legal certainty and consistency in determining national disaster status. Key Findings Highlights The Aceh 2004 case is presented as consistent with the indicators established under Article 7 paragraph (2). Comparative cases reveal differences in the application of the statutory indicators across major events. The study proposes clearer measurable benchmarks through a Presidential Regulation under Article 7 paragraph (3). Keywords : National Disaster, Disaster Status Determination, Disaster Management, Legal Certainty, Disaster Indicators
Liability of Pharmaceutical Companies in Drug Quality Assurance: Tanggung Gugat Perusahaan Farmasi Dalam Penjaminan Kualitas Obat Faiza Fitrianisa; Lidya Shery Muis
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1668

Abstract

General Background: Pharmaceutical companies have legal obligations to ensure the quality, safety, and proper distribution of medicines delivered to consumers. Specific Background: Drug quality assurance involves production and distribution standards, including Good Manufacturing Practices and Good Distribution Practices, while consumers require legal protection when medicines are defective or do not meet applicable standards. Knowledge Gap: Previous studies discussed pharmaceutical production, regulatory supervision, and drug distribution, but this study specifically examines the legal liability of pharmaceutical companies for drug quality defects throughout the distribution process. Aims: This study analyzes the legal obligations of pharmaceutical companies in maintaining drug quality and examines the relationship between Good Distribution Practices, product liability, consumer protection law, civil law, and health law. Results: Using normative legal research with a statutory approach, the study finds that pharmaceutical companies remain the primary legally liable parties for defective medicines, while liability may also arise for Pharmaceutical Wholesalers when defects result from improper distribution, storage, or transportation. Legal mechanisms include compensation, strict liability, product recall, and administrative sanctions where regulatory violations are established. Novelty: The study integrates pharmaceutical company liability with distribution-stage obligations and distinguishes the respective legal positions of pharmaceutical manufacturers and Pharmaceutical Wholesalers. Implications: The findings provide a legal framework for consumer protection and support the development of drug quality supervision and enforcement within the pharmaceutical distribution chain. Key Findings Highlights Pharmaceutical manufacturers remain the primary legally liable parties for defective medicines throughout the distribution chain. Pharmaceutical Wholesalers carry legal obligations concerning storage, transportation, and Good Distribution Practices. Product liability and strict liability operate within a layered legal responsibility system for consumer protection. Keywords : Pharmaceutical Liability, Drug Quality, Consumer Protection, Product Liability, Strict Liability
Alternative Transfer of Land Rights Due to Inheritance Through a Deed of Distribution of Inheritance Rights Reviewed from the Principle of Publicity: Alternatif Peralihan Hak atas Tanah karena Pewarisan Melalui Akta Pembagian Hak Waris Ditinjau pada Prinsip Publisitas Yeni Dewi Anggraeni; Sri Budi Purwaningsih
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1670

Abstract

General Background: Land rights transfer due to inheritance requires legal certainty and proper registration to establish the legal status of land rights. Specific Background: The Inheritance Rights Distribution Deed (Akta Pembagian Hak Waris/APHW) is recognized as a document in inheritance-based land registration, but its position as a direct basis for land rights transfer remains subject to different interpretations. Knowledge Gap: Previous studies have discussed the validity and registration of APHW, while differences in its practical implementation between Land Offices remain an important issue. Aims: This study analyzes the legal position of APHW as an alternative mechanism for inheritance-based land rights transfer from the perspective of the publicity principle and examines its implementation at the Land Offices of Sidoarjo Regency and Pasuruan Regency. Results: Using normative legal research with a statutory approach, supported by interviews, the study finds that APHW may serve as a basis for inheritance-based land rights transfer when all heirs have agreed on the distribution and the change is registered. The Land Office of Sidoarjo Regency accepts APHW as a direct basis for transfer, whereas the Land Office of Pasuruan Regency requires inheritance registration followed by a Deed of Joint Rights Distribution (APHB). Novelty: The study connects the normative position of APHW with differences in legal interpretation and administrative implementation between two Land Offices. Implications: Clearer regulatory harmonization and technical guidelines are needed to establish legal certainty and uniformity in inheritance-based land registration. Kye Finding Highlights APHW Is Recognized As A Document For Inheritance-Based Land Registration. Sidoarjo And Pasuruan Apply Different Interpretations To APHW. Regulatory Harmonization Is Needed For Uniform Land Registration Practices. Keywords : Inheritance Rights Distribution Deed, Land Rights Transfer, Publicity Principle, Land Registration, Legal Certainty
Protection of Patients' Rights to Optimal Health Services in Multi-Site Physician Practices in Sidoarjo Regency: Perlindungan Hak Pasien Atas Pelayanan Kesehatan Yang Optimal Terhadap Praktik Multi-Tempat Dokter di Kabupaten Sidoarjo Achmad Bayu Setiawan; Lidya Shery Muis
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1671

Abstract

General Background: Patient rights to safe, quality, and medically appropriate health services are protected by Indonesian health law. Specific Background: Physicians may practice at more than one health facility, but scheduling, consultation time, communication, and workload can affect the fulfillment of patient rights. Knowledge Gap: Although Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health establishes patients’ rights and physicians’ professional obligations, the implementation of these protections in multi-site physician practices in Sidoarjo requires empirical examination. Aims: This study analyzes legal protection of patient rights in multi-site physician practices in Sidoarjo by comparing legal provisions with conditions in practice. Results: Using an empirical juridical method with statutory and conceptual approaches, data were collected through interviews with five physicians, questionnaires involving 66 patients, observations, and documentation studies and analyzed descriptively and qualitatively. The findings show that patient rights were generally fulfilled at a fairly good level, while consultation time remained inadequate and scheduling required attention. Physicians reported that patient volume, movement between facilities, dense schedules, and limited rest time could increase workload. Novelty: The study connects statutory protection of patient rights with patient perceptions and physician experiences in multi-site practice in Sidoarjo. Implications: The findings support clearer scheduling management, workload evaluation, coordination among health facilities, continuous service-quality supervision, and accessible complaint mechanisms to maintain patient rights and quality healthcare. Key Findings Highlights 66 Patients Reported Generally Adequate Fulfillment Of Their Healthcare Rights. Consultation Duration Remained A Major Area Requiring Attention. Five Physicians Identified Workload And Scheduling As Practical Constraints. Keywords : Patient Rights, Legal Protection, Healthcare Services, Physician Practices, Health Law
State Responsibility in Compensation for Death Sentenced Person on Judicial Error: Pertanggungjawaban Negara dalam Ganti Rugi Bagi Terpidana Mati atas Kekhilafan Hakim Alifian Maulana Nanda Pradana; Emy Rosna Wati
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1673

Abstract

General Background: Judicial error in criminal proceedings raises serious legal concerns when a death sentence has already been executed because the resulting loss of life cannot be restored. Specific Background: Indonesian law recognizes compensation for wrongful judicial processes, while the application of compensation and rehabilitation to wrongful executions requires specific legal arrangements. Knowledge Gap: Existing regulations do not yet provide sufficiently detailed standards for compensation calculation, independent examination procedures, specific provisions for wrongful execution, or a specialized institution to administer compensation. Aims: This study analyzes state accountability for compensation to death-sentenced persons affected by judicial error and examines the reconstruction of state responsibility in Indonesia and other legal systems. Results: Using normative juridical research with conceptual, statutory, and comparative approaches, the study finds that Law Number 20 of 2025 on the Criminal Procedure Code recognizes state responsibility for compensation following judicial review through a state endowment fund mechanism. However, procedural and institutional gaps remain. The comparison with the United Kingdom and Taiwan identifies more developed mechanisms concerning compensation, administration, assessment, and rehabilitation. Novelty: This study constructs a compensation and rehabilitation framework addressing wrongful execution and the resulting rights of heirs and families. Implications: The findings support clearer regulatory arrangements for compensation standards, payment procedures, institutional responsibilities, and rehabilitation following judicial error. Key Findings Highlights Indonesian Law Recognizes Compensation Through A State Endowment Fund Mechanism. Compensation Standards And Independent Examination Procedures Remain Insufficiently Regulated. United Kingdom And Taiwan Provide Comparative Models For Administrative And Compensation Arrangements. Keywords : State Accountability, Wrongful Execution, Judicial Error, Criminal Compensation, Legal Reconstruction
Exoneration Clauses in Robot Trading Agreements in the Indonesian Consumer Protection Legal System: Klausul Pembebasan Tanggung Jawab dalam Perjanjian Perdagangan Otomatis dalam Sistem Hukum Perlindungan Konsumen Indonesia M. Hendriansyah Raihan; Mochammad Tanzil Multazam
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1675

Abstract

General Background: The development of digital investment services has introduced automated trading systems such as robot trading into contractual relationships between business actors and consumers in Indonesia. Specific Background: Robot trading agreements may contain exoneration clauses that limit or transfer the responsibility of service providers for losses incurred by consumers. Knowledge Gap: Previous studies have examined robot trading, illegal investment, and consumer protection, but limited attention has been given to the normative relationship between exoneration clauses in robot trading agreements, Article 18 of the Indonesian Consumer Protection Law, and the hierarchy of legislation. Aims: This study analyzes the regulation of exoneration clauses under Bappebti Regulation Number 12 of 2022, examines their conformity with Indonesian consumer protection law, and analyzes potential normative conflicts based on the principle of lex superior derogat legi inferiori. Results: Using normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, and analytical approaches, the study finds that sectoral regulation may provide limited room for responsibility restrictions when transparency requirements are fulfilled. However, clauses that unilaterally transfer business actors’ responsibility to consumers may conflict with Article 18 of the Consumer Protection Law. In such circumstances, the higher legal norm must prevail, and conflicting clauses may be declared null and void. Novelty: This study specifically examines exoneration clauses in robot trading agreements through the interaction between sectoral regulation, consumer protection law, and normative hierarchy. Implications: The findings provide a normative basis for assessing the validity of exoneration clauses and maintaining consistency between sectoral regulation and consumer protection law. Key Findings Highlights Indonesia’s Consumer Protection Law Prohibits Unilateral Liability Transfers. Transparency Does Not Override Higher Consumer Protection Norms. Lex Superior Determines Conflicting Norms Within The Regulatory Hierarchy. Keywords : Exoneration Clauses, Robot Trading, Consumer Protection, Normative Conflict, Legal Hierarchy
The Risk of Breach of Contract in Fish Trading Practices Without Payment Guarantees at the Sidoarjo Fish Auction Site : Risiko Wanprestasi dalam Praktik Jual Beli Ikan Tanpa Jaminan Pembayaran di Tempat Pelelangan Ikan Sidoarjo Muhammad Adil ‘Azmi; Sri Budi Purwaningsih
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1676

Abstract

General Background: Fish trading activities at the Sidoarjo Fish Auction Site (TPI Sidoarjo) commonly rely on oral agreements and mutual trust between borg and pengkulak. Specific Background: These transactions are frequently conducted without payment guarantees, particularly when trusted pengkulak receive payment terms that allow settlement after the fish has been sold. Knowledge Gap: Existing studies have discussed breach of contract, creditor protection, oral agreements, and fish trading practices, but limited attention has been given to the specific characteristics and legal risks of uncollateralized fish transactions at TPI Sidoarjo. Aims: This study examines breach of contract risks in fish trading without payment guarantees and analyzes the role of TPI supervisors in assisting dispute resolution. Results: Using an empirical socio-legal approach supported by statutory and conceptual approaches, the study draws on semi-structured interviews with 21 informants consisting of 10 borgs, 10 pengkulak, and 1 TPI supervisor. The findings show that oral agreements remain legally valid when the requirements of Article 1320 of the Indonesian Civil Code are fulfilled. The most common form of default is delayed payment, while total payment failure occurs less frequently. Delayed payment disrupts borgs' working capital, delays payments to fishermen, increases collection costs, and creates the possibility of accumulated or uncollectible receivables. TPI supervisors primarily facilitate deliberation without authority to impose legal sanctions. Novelty: The study connects empirical trading practices at TPI Sidoarjo with Indonesian contract law and the practical role of TPI supervision in dispute resolution. Implications: The findings highlight the need for more orderly transaction records, controlled payment terms, and continued good-faith fulfillment of contractual obligations. Key Findings Highlights Oral Transactions Remain Legally Valid Under Article 1320. Delayed Payment Is the Dominant Form of Default. TPI Supervisors Facilitate Deliberation Without Sanctioning Authority. Keywords : Breach Of Contract, Fish Trading, Payment Guarantees, Contract Law, TPI Sidoarjo
Material Flow Cost Accounting and Its Role in Reducing Loss Costs and Enhancing Product Sustainability: An Applied Study in the General Company for Textile and Leather Industries Alaa Jassim Salman
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 4 (2026): November
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i4.1677

Abstract

General Background: Industrial manufacturing processes are increasingly challenged by rising resource costs and growing environmental responsibilities regarding production waste. Specific Background: Conventional costing systems typically fail to trace or report the specific costs of losses and non-productive material flows separately. Knowledge Gap: Detailed empirical tracking of physical material and energy movements across successive textile manufacturing stages using standardized environmental accounting remains limited. Aims: This study aims to examine the role of Material Flow Cost Accounting (MFCA) in identifying loss costs and evaluating potential reductions to promote product sustainability. Results: Applying MFCA revealed that loss costs accounted for 3.288% of total material flow costs, and proposed improvements could reduce these costs by approximately 15.46% while raising the material utilization rate to 91.791%. Novelty: The implementation of ISO 14051-based material flow cost accounting within the Iraqi textile and leather sector specifically pinpoints distinct production stage loss burdens. Implications: Manufacturing enterprises can systematically optimize resource efficiency and strengthen both economic and environmental dimensions of product sustainability by utilizing MFCA data. Key Findings Highlights Material flow cost accounting successfully isolates and reveals non-productive loss costs separately from conforming finished product expenses. Cutting and knitting stages exhibit significant loss quantities and financial burdens that require prioritized corrective action. Proposed optimization measures can significantly decrease overall loss rates while simultaneously improving material utilization efficiency and economic performance. Keywords Material Flow Cost Accounting, Loss Costs, Negative Product, Cost Reduction, Product Sustainability
Liability of Online Loan Application Providers to Third Parties for Misuse of Personal Data: Tanggung Jawab Penyelenggara Aplikasi Pinjaman Online kepada Pihak Ketiga atas Penyalahgunaan Data Pribadi Rio Hendrawan; Mochammad Tanzil Multazam
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 1 (2026): February
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i1.1678

Abstract

Abstract. General Background: The growth of online lending services has created new challenges in personal data protection, particularly during debt collection. Specific Background: Personal data obtained through online lending applications may be used to contact third parties who have no legal relationship with the loan agreement. Knowledge Gap: Previous studies have largely focused on debtors and have not systematically examined non-emergency contacts as third parties whose privacy rights may be violated during online lending collection practices. Aims: This study analyzes the forms and methods of personal data misuse involving non-emergency contacts and examines the legal responsibility of online lending application providers for such misuse. Results: Using normative legal research with statutory and conceptual approaches, the study identifies contact injection, spamming and blast messages, robocalls, and false claims that third parties are guarantors as forms of personal data misuse. These practices violate personal data protection principles and third-party privacy rights. Online lending providers may bear administrative, civil, and criminal liability under the Personal Data Protection Law, Electronic Information and Transactions Law, Financial Services Authority regulations, and the AFPI Code of Conduct. Novelty: The study places non-emergency contacts as third-party legal subjects whose personal data and privacy rights require specific legal protection in online lending collection practices. Implications: The findings highlight the need for stronger supervision, compliance with personal data protection principles, and ethical debt collection practices to protect third-party privacy rights. Key Findings Highlights Non-emergency contacts can become secondary victims of collection practices. Multiple collection methods involve unauthorized third-party data processing. Providers may face administrative, civil, and criminal liability. Keywords : Online Lending, Personal Data Protection, Third Parties, Legal Responsibility, Debt Collection