Background: Rubrics are widely recognized for establishing clear criteria, enhancing objectivity, and promoting consistency in assessment. Despite their perceived benefits, considerable debates and challenges persist regarding their practical implementation, reliability, and validity across diverse educational contexts. Objective: This study synthesizes the existing literature on rubrics, focusing on their role in facilitating learning, supporting fair assessment, and addressing issues of psychometric quality (reliability and validity). Method: A systematic literature review approach was employed to analyze empirical and theoretical studies from peer-reviewed journals. The analytical procedure encompassed data identification, classification, qualitative synthesis, and conclusion verification through literature triangulation. Results: The findings indicate that while rubrics significantly enhance transparency and student self-regulation, their efficacy heavily depends on instructional context and design rigor. Successful adoption requires incorporating core psychometric principles, avoiding rigid structural pitfalls, giving teachers contextual autonomy, and engaging in continuous iterative calibration to maintain fairness and validity. Conclusion: Rubrics serve as powerful formative and summative assessment tools only when purposefully designed, context-sensitive, and continually refined rather than mechanically applied. Originality/Value: This review article offers conceptual novelty in the field of educational assessment and evaluation by synthesizing current literature on the practical challenges, potentials, reliability, and validity of rubrics, which remain underexplored comprehensively across diverse contexts. It maps existing theoretical-methodological gaps, serving as a strategic reference and contributing to guiding future research agendas and establishing practical frameworks for effective rubric design.
Copyrights © 2025