Jurnal Al-Tadzkiyyah
Vol 17 No 3 (2026): Al-Tadzkiyyah: Jurnal Pendidikan Islam

Toward an Evidence-Informed Cognitive-Emotional-Spiritual Framework for Tolerance in Multicultural Islamic Education: An Integrative Review

Erda Ermawati (Unknown)
Ahmad Zumaro (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
12 Sep 2026

Abstract

Research on tolerance in Islamic education often fragments cognitive, emotional-intergroup, and spiritual-ethical processes, while the evidence for these domains is not equally direct. This integrative review examines which mechanisms are associated with tolerance, prejudice reduction, multicultural competence, or prosocial intergroup behavior; how they can be coordinated pedagogically; and how evidence strength and boundary conditions qualify the proposed integration. The fixed analytic corpus comprised 43 substantive journal studies from an auditable full-text eligibility set of 47 DOI-bearing articles; four methodological articles informed review procedures but were not coded as substantive evidence. Because the archival search log did not preserve source-level identification and deduplication counts, upstream PRISMA counts were not reconstructed. A deductive-inductive synthesis coded construct boundaries, mechanism, outcome directness, context, and transferability, while claim strength was calibrated by evidence role and design leverage. The evidence is asymmetric: emotional-intergroup mechanisms have the most direct and synthesis-level support; cognitive-epistemic mechanisms have convergent but partly mechanistic support; and spiritual-ethical evidence is largely construct or adjacent-outcome evidence. Excluding non-tolerance spiritual-intelligence outcomes leaves the spiritual pathway as an ethical design hypothesis rather than an empirically co-equal pillar. The resulting framework coordinates critical understanding, regulated perspective engagement, and ethically grounded action while treating power, majority-minority position, teacher competence, curriculum representation, and contact quality as moderators. It is offered as an evidence-informed design proposition for direct empirical testing, not as a validated causal model.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

tadzkiyyah

Publisher

Subject

Education

Description

Al-Tadzkiyyah: Jurnal Pendidikan Islam discussed the raised issues concerning Islamic education and unbiased exchange of information on the results of scientific studies or research for scholars and practitioners in the field of Islamic education in theory and practice, and research learning Islamic ...